• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

2026 Steelers draft grades

I think you are going to find that issue was never talent related... it was scheme and technique... it showed up coinciding with our defensive gurus overhauling the line scheme that had been in place since the blitztburgh days, to one where the DLinemen weren't eating blocks and gaps and were " stopping the run on the way to the QB"
I understand your point however, I think it’s been more talent related as of late..
And sometimes it was more about the want to, than the talent, especially when you’re talking about playing physical run defense..

And I have on many occasions, watched the lack of effort and “want to” from our run stoppers in the middle of the defense lately..
 
You sure can tell the difference between a Tomlin draft and the McCarthy draft. From a positional standpoint, it is looking like McCarthy is gearing up the offense to be a high scoring/big play offense. It’ll probably take another draft/offseason to transition to what he wants to do with the team to get it ready for the modern NFL.
 
They also have Black from last year who is big enough and stout enough to play NT. He played pretty well last year as a rookie. If he and Harmon take a nice leap this offseason, the DL, Watt, and Highsmith will look a good bit different this year. Watt very well may jump back up to 15 sacks if they can't have 2 or 3 guys blocking and chipping him.
 
Ty Simpson going earlier than anyone expected makes me suspect that several teams were interested in him and wonder if he would’ve been the Steelers first round pick.
 
They also have Black from last year who is big enough and stout enough to play NT. He played pretty well last year as a rookie. If he and Harmon take a nice leap this offseason, the DL, Watt, and Highsmith will look a good bit different this year. Watt very well may jump back up to 15 sacks if they can't have 2 or 3 guys blocking and chipping him.
I love and hope your scenario comes true… but there’s a lot of IF in that summary..

And that makes me a little bit nervous going in the next year..

As you can probably tell, I’m a big believer to win football games….
You have to be able to run the ball, and stop the run.
 
Wetjen was probably my favorite pick. this kid is electrifying. can change the field in a heart beat...

Least favorite pick is Aller. wish the kid the best But I hated picking a QB anywhere this draft.
 
As you can probably tell, I’m a big believer to win football games….
You have to be able to run the ball, and stop the run
I am too.

With that said though, I think the previous coaching staff had some major issues with how they used the players they had. These coaches seem to be more flexible in their thinking, getting back to the old 3-4 D where a big role for the Dline is keeping the ILBs clean to make plays. Too often those ILBs had to make plays downfield, and I think it was often a schematic flaw. With the addition of S. Joseph-Day and another year of experience from Harmon and Black, plus a likely move of Benton from NT duty on running plays, I think you'll see a much better result.

In addition, I see the D-backfield as much improved this year. The Steelers D was wildly inconsistent last year, and got gouged big time almost every game on 3rd and long (i.e. 7 yards or more, often much more). So many times our pass-rush on 3rd down disasters needed an extra half a second to disrupt the play, but our D-backfield was letting folks run wide open in the middle of the field. I think with JPJ, Dean, and the other guys, we will use man & press more than ever, resulting in more sacks, more pressures, more TOs and a better 3rd down stop rate. Oh yeah, and all that means less points against, too.

I don't particularly like our ILBs, but we really didn't have a meaningful chance to address that in this draft. By the time we got to 3rd round picks, those that could make an impact this year were gone. Like the run on TEs, I don't think we anticipated the draft to fall as it did. As a short-term answer, I would dump Harrison and get Elandon Roberts back. He played for Patrick Graham and is still a physical, tone-setting run stuffer. 10-15 snaps a game on obvious run downs would be a big help.

Our D will be much better this year with the change in staff. We have plenty of talent, but our scheme got way old and way predictable.
 
I was really hoping the Steelers could somehow turn some of those day 3 picks into meaningful picks for 2027, but it seems there was little action across the league all weekend for 2027 picks

Lots of holes for next year, with likely needs at QB, TE, DL, ILB and S.

Hopefully that's it. The Steelers need to sign Boz and JPJ ASAP. Probably Herbig too.
 
Wetjen was probably my favorite pick. this kid is electrifying. can change the field in a heart beat...

Least favorite pick is Aller. wish the kid the best But I hated picking a QB anywhere this draft.
I was inside the stadium when the picks were being made.

When Simpson was picked, the crowd was ecstatic. No one wanted him to be available when we picked.
When Beck was picked, the crowd was ecstatic. No one wanted him to be available when we picked.

When Allar was picked... "whaaaaat"? Seemed everyone was surprised at this pick.

The more I read about him, the less I dislike the pick.
 
If the Steelers had selected Oscar Delp TE Georgia with pick 121 rather than the return guy, this draft would rock. The team could then snag Heidenreich with pick 230 just as they did and see how he is returning kicks. He returned a couple punts for Navy in 2024. Delp would have helped the TE room quite a bit and was available in the 4th round, later than most projections had him going.
 
I think Iheanachor will eventually be looked back on as a solid pick, and Germie is a good fit. But it's mostly going to be Allar who makes or breaks this draft. I would have added Dominique Orange, the big DT from Iowa State, in that spot. Emmanuel Pregnon with the #85 pick made sense to me, but they addressed IOL later with Dunker, so I guess I'm OK with that.

Day 3 is where more question marks come in. Wetjen was taken way too high. I would've grabbed Skyler Bell there. Rubio probably wouldn't have been drafted....I take Taylen Green in the fifth, and Nowakowski who is still probably still on the board in round 6. The two seventh round guys are fine for flyers.

All-in-all, I'd give the draft a C+ with a lot of room for improvement if Max and Drew develop.
Early in Khan's tenure, he took big swings on guys on day 3. I liked trying to find starters rather than limited upside role players and I think that's the approach you were taking with your suggestions. Then again, I hope Wetjen becomes the best returner in the league and I'll praise the pick.
 
The predominant theme of the 2026 Steelers’ draft is an average of 1.5 rounds early. We could also call it a geriatric’s sex life.
 
You sure can tell the difference between a Tomlin draft and the McCarthy draft. From a positional standpoint, it is looking like McCarthy is gearing up the offense to be a high scoring/big play offense. It’ll probably take another draft/offseason to transition to what he wants to do with the team to get it ready for the modern NFL.
Another two OL, except now you have Campen and Evans developing them. I like that combo more than the previous OL coaches.
 
Wetjen was probably my favorite pick. this kid is electrifying. can change the field in a heart beat...

Least favorite pick is Aller. wish the kid the best But I hated picking a QB anywhere this draft.
I didnt mind a low round pick or even a lower mid round... like a fourth... a high third means he is the guy who is assured a roster spot... if he comes in and looks like year 1 Landry Jones, he is still taking up a spot... meaning if Rodgers signs, it will be between experienced Rudolph, and completely raw Howard.. Howard would have to be pitch perfect all camp and preseason to get a team to carry two novices.. and if he is that good, then the Allar pick was a waste anyways...
I was inside the stadium when the picks were being made.

When Simpson was picked, the crowd was ecstatic. No one wanted him to be available when we picked.
When Beck was picked, the crowd was ecstatic. No one wanted him to be available when we picked.

When Allar was picked... "whaaaaat"? Seemed everyone was surprised at this pick.

The more I read about him, the less I dislike the pick.
a friend of mine at the draft said everyone was completely shocked by the pick...

I get why they took him, and I hope they are right, but if his instincts are as bad as all my penn stat friends seem to think, there can be a lot of really bad scenarios that play out where he looks good enough to drag out them adding another qb but isnt good enough to win big.. his physical assets are really good, so nfl teams tend to hang on to those guys a long time..

Hopefully he just figures it all out quick that or completely tanks it and we dont spend 8 years in limbo with him and dont reinvest in the position while we still have McCarthy...
 
One thing I have to say about Rubio.. is that when he was healthy and got opportunities he was very noticeable on that defensive line for the fighting Irish..
As mentioned, the kid has absolutely the weight (although could be a couple inches taller) and skill set to be a successfuldefensive end in our 34 scheme..
And yes, if you put number 91 on his jersey and change the colors, his mannerisms on the field of play does look like Aaron Smith.. and remember it took Aaron Smith a couple years to reach his potential, and I believe Rubio can follow in the same path.

Here’s some tape of a kid you tell me he doesn’t honestly remind you of Aaron Smith..


Not sure about the Aaron Smith comp, and it's a bit concerning when you have a guy who played for 5 years at Notre Dame, he had a grand total of 1.5 sacks in 39 games, and he has a highlight tape of only 2 minutes and 40 seconds.
 
When Allar was picked... "whaaaaat"? Seemed everyone was surprised at this pick.

The more I read about him, the less I dislike the pick.
What's growing on you?

How Allar threw Penn State's 2024 season away against Notre Dame, or how he threw the 2025 season away against Oregon?
 
Early in Khan's tenure, he took big swings on guys on day 3. I liked trying to find starters rather than limited upside role players and I think that's the approach you were taking with your suggestions. Then again, I hope Wetjen becomes the best returner in the league and I'll praise the pick.
It's pretty hard to find guys on day 3 who are going to start out of the gate. Skyler Bell would not have been that for the Steelers, but I bet he will start for Buffalo. And he could have added solidified the depth in Pittsburgh's WR room. Wetjen does serve a purpose, though, because they needed a good return man for sure.
 
What's growing on you?

How Allar threw Penn State's 2024 season away against Notre Dame, or how he threw the 2025 season away against Oregon?
its a very slippery slope for me. i want to believe in Allar, and have read that he has all the tools to compete, but didn't have the weapons at Penn State. I want to believe that if he did have the weapons at Penn State that he'd have won a natty.

which brings me full circle to Will Howard - whom I'm firmly entrenched for as our starter in '26.

if Allar had Howard's weapons (or similar) would he be dismissed as having to just throw the ball up?
 
If the Steelers had selected Oscar Delp TE Georgia with pick 121 rather than the return guy, this draft would rock. The team could then snag Heidenreich with pick 230 just as they did and see how he is returning kicks. He returned a couple punts for Navy in 2024. Delp would have helped the TE room quite a bit and was available in the 4th round, later than most projections had him going.
psst, drunkencounselor, Delp went in the 3rd round, at pick 73.
 
Not sure about the Aaron Smith comp, and it's a bit concerning when you have a guy who played for 5 years at Notre Dame, he had a grand total of 1.5 sacks in 39 games, and he has a highlight tape of only 2 minutes and 40 seconds.
Yeah, maybe a little over the top with the comparison overall..
And yes, he didn’t play a whole lot, especially early on but injuries had a lot to do with it last year..
My point is the guy has needed attributes to be a outstanding defensive end with how we run our 34 defense , similar to what Aaron Smith gave us all those years.. not to mention physically he looks the part and similar to Aaron..
And one last thing… I’m sure all of us had no clue who Aaron Smith was out of Northern Colorado when he was drafted..
You just never know…
 
Last edited:
It's pretty hard to find guys on day 3 who are going to start out of the gate. Skyler Bell would not have been that for the Steelers, but I bet he will start for Buffalo. And he could have added solidified the depth in Pittsburgh's WR room. Wetjen does serve a purpose, though, because they needed a good return man for sure.
I wanted to see the Steelers draft Skyler Bell… I thought he would be a great number three guy in the slot, and also play the Z when needed..

However, we did select a talented kid in the second role to fill that role..

If anybody is in to fantasy football, my suggestion would be to take a flyer on Skyler Bell in your draft..
The other wide receiver, I would take a flyer on in fantasy football would be Jacoby Lane, who went to the ravens… he’s gonna be very good in the red zone for Lamar and also with the occasional deep ball, that he likes to throw..
 
Top