• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Suppose a new franchise is born in the NFL. What do they need most in order of impo

Front Office:
1. Owner - Let the football people do the football work.
2. GM/HC - There are different ways for success. A team with a very strong GM can have a weak HC as a result and the team doesn't succeed. I do think an excellent coach can do more to overcome a weaker GM, so I'd slightly put HC ahead, but you need a pair that can work together.
3. OC - Only because the NFL is about scoring points.
4. DC - Just behind the OC for the reason above.

Team:
1. QB - It's a quarterback league. Since 2004, only Flacco and Foles have won titles while not being considered elite QBs.
2. Pass rusher - With passing being at a premium in the NFL, a dominant pass rusher is the difference maker on defense.
3. CB- It's pretty easy for the offense. If you can pair a great pass rusher with a shutdown cornerback, your defense can actually carry your team to wins.
4. LT - Got to keep the QB healthy.
5. WR1 - They may not get RB touches, but they are the impact players on an offense.
6. S - An elite safety can really make a difference in the middle of the field.
7. WR2/TE - You need a secondary receiving option to take the pressure off WR1. It just depends on how you want to build your offense.
8. ILB - Agree that a three-down ILB is a important position with all of the defensive packages with an extra DB in the lineup.
9. DE - A guy who can do it all will help control the trenches.
10. DT/NT - Again, I still value a defense that can control the line.
11. CB2 - You need three good CBs.
12. Pass Rusher 2 - They don't need to be elite, but rather competent.
13. C - I'm biased because I've seen nothing but great centers in Pittsburgh.
14. Athletic guard - I don't care if it's LG (Faneca) or RG (DeCastro), it's an underrated part of the offense.
15. RT - After watching bad RTs, you still want to keep your QB healthy.
16. DL - Whoever is missing on the DL goes here.
17. Nickelback - Again, you need three good CBs.
18. Starting S - I'll take one great one and one average.
19. G - The other guard position.
20 - RB - A great running back can transform an offense, but a great OL can make average backs look excellent.
21. ILB2 - Run stuffer is fine.
22. K - They put points on the board.
23. LS - If they mess up, it can have terrible results.
24. P - The Steelers have won Super Bowls with bad punters.
 
Does he get to pick players from other nfl teams though?

Yes, that’s what happened when the Panthers, Jags, and Browns were expansion teams.

There would be some good talent available too as teams would try to get rid of players with high cap charges.
 
1. owner
2. GM
3. HC
4. DC
5. OC
6. QB
The rest.

If there is dysfunction at the top, it isn't going to happen on the field. So when I say owner number one. that person needs to let the football people handle football and be given whatever tools the GM and HC and players need.

Thanks for commenting. I think your franchise QB has to be #1 or #2 as he's the key to winning and " the face of the franchise "

I do agree GM > Head coach for the most part.
 
Top