Both their organizations are hot garbage, but they've both won a playoff game this decade, and even the Bengals have a QB that all but like 3 or 4 teams would take in a heart beat.
So??????????
- Thread starter Coryea
- Start date
They are. Look, I said in the one post that I prefer they don't resign Rodgers. But all I'm saying is it's easy for me or us to say that. There are players impacted by these decisions.
Agreed, but Watt signed his extension Ben's final season, so he knew Ben was retiring after the season and Cam signed his big contract with Fields and Wilson at QB.
Yeah, those are valid points.
- Joined
- Apr 23, 2014
- Messages
- 12,078
- Reaction score
- 7,887
- Points
- 113
Rodgers is not holding this team hostage i do not get that argument. Everyone knew all along he was coming last year. We also don't know who they tried to acquire this off season. There were not many options out there. Im also pretty sure they know what is going on with Rodgers right now they just are not telling anyone. I would personally pass on Rodgers just due to mobility alone. If Howard is absolutely terrible we can roll with Mason. I do think Rodgers will be back though
It's not holding them hostage necessarily, it's the fact that he looked bad vs good teams last year, and the team got embarrassed again in the playoffs, so if he's playing his a%% should be here trying to help the team that got embarrassed get better, working with the new guys, the new staff. Them waiting around for a guy that's going to turn 43 to decide when his ego will allow him to return is embarrassing, and just another year of having no clue what their doing at the most important position in sports.
Mahomes, Allen, Darnold, Lamar, Stafford are all at or attended voluntary workouts.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Apr 13, 2014
- Messages
- 5,368
- Reaction score
- 4,961
- Points
- 113
I think people worry way too much about Rogers. His decision is not impacting this draft. Period. End Stop.
The lack of QB talent is what is impacting our decisions. I mean, honestly, do we think letting Rogers determine whether Simpson is worth the #21 pick overall is any way to run scouting department/front office? Of course not.
Do you think HAVING Rogers under contract would PREVENT us from drafting Simpson if everyone in the front office/head coach thinks Simpson is worth the #21 overall pick and a potential long-term QB for this team? Of course not.
So why do you care?
After tonight, depending on the selection or trades, we can ALL decide if those are good or bad. But I just don't see any way Rogers is impacting that at all right now. And I think those that think his little 43-year old slow playing a decision to play or not matter at all to what we are doing is just kind of silly.
The time I am worrying about Rogers is right before training camp starts. Because I DO think the #1 guy on our depth chart has to be getting the reps to implement the new McCarthy system. That is right and proper to expect your starting QB to be apart of that process.
That is the drop dead date where I would tell Rogers to go pack sand. Before that? Eh... our QB room is just a bunch of guys anyhow. And there really hasn't been a good opportunity to cost effectively change that up to this point in the off-season (at least in my opinion).
The lack of QB talent is what is impacting our decisions. I mean, honestly, do we think letting Rogers determine whether Simpson is worth the #21 pick overall is any way to run scouting department/front office? Of course not.
Do you think HAVING Rogers under contract would PREVENT us from drafting Simpson if everyone in the front office/head coach thinks Simpson is worth the #21 overall pick and a potential long-term QB for this team? Of course not.
So why do you care?
After tonight, depending on the selection or trades, we can ALL decide if those are good or bad. But I just don't see any way Rogers is impacting that at all right now. And I think those that think his little 43-year old slow playing a decision to play or not matter at all to what we are doing is just kind of silly.
The time I am worrying about Rogers is right before training camp starts. Because I DO think the #1 guy on our depth chart has to be getting the reps to implement the new McCarthy system. That is right and proper to expect your starting QB to be apart of that process.
That is the drop dead date where I would tell Rogers to go pack sand. Before that? Eh... our QB room is just a bunch of guys anyhow. And there really hasn't been a good opportunity to cost effectively change that up to this point in the off-season (at least in my opinion).
There are some things I assume will never change.. one of which is that a significant amount of steelers fans will always hate the starting qb and want a different one... even with Ben.. been true since I was a kid abd I dont see it changing anytime soon...
