• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Landry Jones

We wouldn't have this problem if we had Randolph Scott….


 
You're missing the bigger point, just like some did in the Dri Archer thread. The angst isn't necessarily over a "3rd string QB." The angst is over the fact that he was drafted to begin with, and that he has proven unworthy of a roster spot, yet is still on the team. The venom is aimed at CMT and managements judgement.

So of all QB's drafted in the NFL...how many actually make it? Or are they mostly like Landry? The front office thought they saw something in him...it hasn't worked out. It happens. The issue I have is they keep him on the roster when they could easily put him on the practice squad without no one grabbing him. And will say this....I don't think they drafted him to be a 3rd stringer...they wanted a 2nd stringer with this pick. Unfortunately it obviously hasn't worked out.
 
Cut Jones now. Maybe next week we can see more of that kid from Clemson, you know, Tomlin's homeboy from Hampton VA...........
 
I didn't get a chance to watch the game last night but I'm watching it today. You know he doesn't look all that bad. I only saw one sack and he did have a few nicely thrown balls. I also noticed a lot of dropped balls. Oh and by the way I saw J. James catch 2.
 
I had no problem drafting him... if you think you have a shot at a quality QB, you always take a shot at one even if it means passing on a PON, because they are that valuable and rare. I had no problem with him being a developmental guy, its just that three years into the development I am not seeing even Dennis Dixon level competency.

The bottom line is he doesn't have a fantastic arm, he doesn't have great mobility, he doesn't have the ability to make quick reads.... his foundation skills are average, and I don't see the benefit of keeping him on the roster trying to build around that
 
Why such a long thread on a 3rd string QB and none on Jarvis Jones?

afraid to use the B word?

cowards
 
Laundry is not a worthy player. Sometimes a back up is found later in the draft he is not. With that in mind we would be better served putting a back up lineman in at quarterback than this guy or a running back. His roster spot could be used to keep the replacement for Harrison if he is on the team now. The time this guy has been kept on the roster we have put another player on the practice squad every year he has been here. We lost the chance at another player when he was selected and lost another player every year he has had the roster spot. Has the team lost any players from the practice squad to other teams while laundry was here? The answer is yes, so in addition to the draft pick when he was taken we have also lost other players that could have been contributors while his dead *** was on the roster. That is way to high a price to pay for what the team has gotten in return.

There is another Jones that seems to suck as well but that is a topic for another thread.
 
I had no problem drafting him... if you think you have a shot at a quality QB, you always take a shot at one even if it means passing on a PON, because they are that valuable and rare. I had no problem with him being a developmental guy, its just that three years into the development I am not seeing even Dennis Dixon level competency.

The bottom line is he doesn't have a fantastic arm, he doesn't have great mobility, he doesn't have the ability to make quick reads.... his foundation skills are average, and I don't see the benefit of keeping him on the roster trying to build around that

I don't think there is one person on this board that will argue your post....but the fact is Colbert believes in carrying 3 QB's on the active roster.
 
Laundry is not a worthy player. Sometimes a back up is found later in the draft he is not. With that in mind we would be better served putting a back up lineman in at quarterback than this guy or a running back. His roster spot could be used to keep the replacement for Harrison if he is on the team now. The time this guy has been kept on the roster we have put another player on the practice squad every year he has been here. We lost the chance at another player when he was selected and lost another player every year he has had the roster spot. Has the team lost any players from the practice squad to other teams while laundry was here? The answer is yes, so in addition to the draft pick when he was taken we have also lost other players that could have been contributors while his dead *** was on the roster. That is way to high a price to pay for what the team has gotten in return.

There is another Jones that seems to suck as well but that is a topic for another thread.

Crying over spilled milk. Colbert carries 3 QB's on his active roster. Bitching about will not change it. It would be nice if we actually had a guy that looked like he was progressing at least while eating up a roster spot. . I get that. Still not going to change anything though.
 
Why such a long thread on a 3rd string QB and none on Jarvis Jones?

afraid to use the B word?

cowards

Ben
Brown
Bell
Bryant


the killer B's !

:towel:
 
If you look around the league, plenty of teams carrying four QB's during pre-season. A lot of these guys will hit the open market in a few weeks.

Here are some #3 and #4 QB's that may - or may not - be better than Landry Jones:

Titans - #3 Charlie Whitehurt #4 Alex Tanney
Rams - #3 Austin Davis #4 Sean Mannion
Chargers - #3 Brad Sorensen #4 Chase Rettig
Eagles - #3 Matt Barkley #4 Tim Tebow
Raiders - #3 Matt McGloin #4 Cody Fajardo
Jets - #3 Bryce Petty #4 Jake Heaps
Saints - #3 Ryan Griffin #4 Garrett Grayson
Vikings- #3 Taylor Heinicke #4 Mike Kafka
Dolphins - #3 Josh Freeman #4 McLeod Bethel-Thompson
Jaguars - #3 Stephen Morris #4 Jeff Tuel
Packers - #3 Matt Blanchard #4 Brett Hundley
Lions - #3 Kellen Moore #4 Garrett Gilbert
Broncos - #3 Zac Dysert #4 Trevor Siemian
Cowboys - #3 Dustin Vaughan #4 Jameill Showers
Browns - #3 Thaddeus Lewis #4 Connor Shaw
Bengals - #3 Josh Johnson #4 Keith Wenning
Bills - #3 EJ Manuel #4 Matt Simms
Cardinals - #3 Logan Thomas #4 Phillip Sims

And the reason this back-up QB thing has me concerned, is that I'm not sold on Gradkowski... would be nice to add some solid depth here before we head into the season. Watching Landry Jones these past two games has made my stomach churn.

Now, which one of those players on the list there can possibly give you more confidence than Landry Jones? It isn't a stellar list. I would not have confidence in any of those guys winning a couple of games if Ben were to go down. Which drives home my point. It is a lot of angst over a 3rd string QB.
 
Now, which one of those players on the list there can possibly give you more confidence than Landry Jones? It isn't a stellar list. I would not have confidence in any of those guys winning a couple of games if Ben were to go down. Which drives home my point. It is a lot of angst over a 3rd string QB.

The only problem I see is we wanted him to be more than a 3rd stringer. At this point in his career the hope was he would be our 2nd stringer....he isn't though. Just part of a long list of BAD third stringers.
 
please don't embarass yourself with those kind of comparisons, come on you are better than that. Harrison and Heyward had the physical tools and lacked experience and technique. Landry lacks everything, especially pocket presence, also is it me or all his passes look like wounded ducks? Has no zip on his throws

Maybe you missed the following sentences that said "I agree that Landry has stuck around too long. Especially on the 53 man roster. All that has been accomplished with him could have been done with him on the PS."

So, no worries and no embarrassment old chap.
 
Ben
Brown
Bell
Bryant


the killer B's !

:towel:

And the uni's to match!

15i0oj9.jpg


There's also Bud Dupree and Brandon Boykin on D.
 
The only problem I see is we wanted him to be more than a 3rd stringer. At this point in his career the hope was he would be our 2nd stringer....he isn't though. Just part of a long list of BAD third stringers.

Right. And I certainly understand that. In an ideal world, you don't have to worry about ever seeing the 2nd stringer either.

I guess maybe it's age. One thing getting older has afforded me is the ability not to worry about things until I must. I'll worry about the backup QBs in the event Ben goes down. I will not waste anytime on it otherwise.
 
Thing is we seen some of Jarvis burst. And he has had a few sacks. (very few)

I agree he isn't as fast and explosive as some others. But if he had the work ethic I think we could get a Haggans type OLber.

Problem is I think his work ethic is questionable at best.

From last years upclose viewing of Heyward bitching his *** out when every other player was up off the bench, to seeing him in camp. He finds that helmet to sit on quickly when he isn't playing.

Some might blow that off as resting when he can.

I simply don't think he is a high effort type consistently.

You might get the occasional glimpse.

But whichever you lean on your opinion, Jarvis needs to improve.

Don't think they will axe him this year, but you have to see that as a real possibility next year.

IF no improvement takes place.
 
Just add Jones to the growing list of ****** high draft picks by this FO.

Yep...burning a 4th(high) on him was horrible.

Well they thought they saw something in him....It hasn't worked out, but I'm not worried about a 4th round pick being used on someone they thought they could turn into a decent backup. Now if they used a 3rd or 2nd maybe. As someone posted earlier there wasn't one player in that draft that has really stood out after this pick. If that is the case I'm even less worried about it.
 
Thing is we seen some of Jarvis burst. And he has had a few sacks. (very few)

I agree he isn't as fast and explosive as some others. But if he had the work ethic I think we could get a Haggans type OLber.

Problem is I think his work ethic is questionable at best.

From last years upclose viewing of Heyward bitching his *** out when every other player was up off the bench, to seeing him in camp. He finds that helmet to sit on quickly when he isn't playing.

Some might blow that off as resting when he can.

I simply don't think he is a high effort type consistently.

You might get the occasional glimpse.

But whichever you lean on your opinion, Jarvis needs to improve.

Don't think they will axe him this year, but you have to see that as a real possibility next year.

IF no improvement takes place.

I think you might be in the wrong Jones' BUST thread. This one is for QB Landry Jones. :)
 
So, let me get this straight. Some yahoo doing the broadcast last night for the JACKSONVILLE side of the game says that Landry Jones is Tomlin's pet project and now that's gospel? Haven't heard any such thing from the LOCAL reporters, but if a JACKSONVILLE shill says it's so, it must be.

Seems legit. :beer:

That Jacksonville play-by-play guy was THE worst pro football announcer I have ever heard. From "Dry" Archer to "Lavon" Bell to "Martavious" Bryant to describing #16 as running a ball that #49 actually carried, he was absolutely laughable.

And I really don't believe Landry Jones was as God-awful as everyone here seems to think. Yes, his YPA was horrible, but several drops didn't help his cause. Of course, thanks to the wizards at NFL network who decided it would be a good idea to cut over four minutes of actual game action IN THE SECOND QUARTER, I was not able to see the full sample.
 
That Jacksonville play-by-play guy was THE worst pro football announcer I have ever heard. From "Dry" Archer to "Lavon" Bell to "Martavious" Bryant to describing #16 as running a ball that #49 actually carried, he was absolutely laughable.

And I really don't believe Landry Jones was as God-awful as everyone here seems to think. Yes, his YPA was horrible, but several drops didn't help his cause. Of course, thanks to the wizards at NFL network who decided it would be a good idea to cut over four minutes of actual game action IN THE SECOND QUARTER, I was not able to see the full sample.

Yeah, they were pretty bad. Larry Thomas (Timmons) lol.

I watched the game again and agree with you. L. Jones was better than first impression. He should have at least 2 more TDs in these two games. He definitely played better against the the Jags than the Vikings. Though I would still sign Matt Flynn :peach:
 
Yeah, they were pretty bad. Larry Thomas (Timmons) lol.

I watched the game again and agree with you. L. Jones was better than first impression. He should have at least 2 more TDs in these two games. He definitely played better against the the Jags than the Vikings. Though I would still sign Matt Flynn :peach:

I watched it in full too last night. He wasn't that bad. He does make some throws that leave you scratching your head, but he had at least 5 drops. And the Coates catch, taking nothing away from Coates, but that was a big league throw. No way around it.
 
Charlie Batch, even retired and out of football, would be WAY better than Landry Jones. I watched the entire game also. Poor clock management and over throwing open receivers are not good signs for even a backup. LJ should be released.
 
Last edited:
Laundry has played a ton vs scrubs this season... he is completing 50% of his pass attempts... he has a paltry 4 yards per attempt. there just isn't anything there to save...cut and move on

He has also played a ton with scrubs all his career. Doubt if he has ever taken a snap with the starters other than in practice.
 
Top