How many years ago was that? I said Troy had a very mediocre rookie year, which is correct, and called him short by the standards of his position. I'm sure everyone here thought he was a hall of fame player back then! This board needs a wayback machine or longer archives. Some would be muzzled based on what they said. Me, oh my I'd have too many I told you so's. Let's get real, if this is the only example you have in 17+ years, what does that say? I have my misses too, but way more hits.
Just a few

busts I've called.
Sweet, Hood, Jones, Burns, Golson, Archer, how many more should I list? I've called my share of hits too that the Steelers pass on or selected The funny thing, at least for me is generic fan types sticking up for these draft picks, and attacking me, only for what I call a victory lap 2-4 years later to say I told you so. Some can't take it. For years I have asked others to ante up, but they seldom speak on who we should have drafted or signed. Few do and when they say something its like
Claypool is a 3rd round talent.
I do enjoy it. Thanks.