I used to love Erhardt in the '90s. I felt like I was looking over his shoulder. It seemed like he was building something as he called plays. This guy now seems like there is a hat laying on the ground beside him and he just pulls plays out.
It's weird though. I watch a lot of football, and it seems like that to me with a lot of teams. So maybe it's me.
I divide up our OCs like this:
Completely out of their depths: Fitchner, Sherman ( not going into them... they just shouldnt have been OCs here...
Fundamentally sound and technically proficient but too conservative --- Moore, Erhardt, Haley...
-Erhardt was just a great run dinosaur... he easily had the best run block schemes, but he overutilized the Te and passes to RBs... he lost most of his playcalling in mid 95 and was forced out after the season
-Moore was a great OC in his first real stin t as an OC... the rooneys forced him out over too conservative play design, which by the end of his career was not an issue
-Haley was brought in to fix The O after Arians... he was magnificent in design but his playcalling was meh... he butted heads with better playcallers at virtually every stop in his career...
High Concept System over Talent guys: Walton, Gilbride (both pushed complex offenses, and called plays to show off more than win games)
Stubborn guys who werent willing to adapt: Mularkey, Arians
-Arians didnt want to adapt his blocking scheme to fit the players he had and refused to utilize anything short... Arians understood the deep passing game better than any other OC we had... his routes were so technically great at opening up the mid to deep stuff... he just hated crossing routes and slants and wasnt ever that great with the run
-Mularkey wanted to run those 2 TE sets and refused to look at more aggressive spread sets. I liked Mike... he used motion very well, he just hated anything too modern and overused trick plays at the 40....
Good guys with short stays
I think our two best OCs were Gailey and Whiz...
Gailey didnt use the TE in the passing game much, and preferred 3 and 4 wr sets a lot... he was always balanced and his routes, motion and gamelans were usually very solid... The Rooneys brought him in after the O was utterly useless in 93... he designed all those routes in 94 and 95 and was the guy who opened up the O... he has adapted a ton through the years and still has an OC job in miami...
Whiz was probably the best all around OC we had. He was equally good at the run and pass fundamentals, understood the game and used motion and playcalls to open up defenses better than most of our OCs... Its kind of a shame he left when he did...