• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Omar evaluation

Was the formula I chose not to take credit if they started somewhere else and each team was evaluated with that same approach. I obviously know that it can be shared or tilted towards the second or third team. Etc.

That would have needed a lot more deciphering on a person to person basis.

Wasn’t really gluing into calling him something.. was more glued into an approach that could compare all the teams in regards to one aspect..



I think you put a lot of work into this and it sure shows in the original post that Kahn has been doing a pretty good job to date.

Things can be argued in many ways, but if the same criteria has been applied to all 32 teams, then it is a legit stat.

Remember the Kahn sat out his first draft because of Colbert being kept on… ( I think that had more to do with coach tomlin).


Thanks for all your great post(s) and insight slash, appreciate yaz…!!!




Salute the nation
 
Tied 5th out of 32, that is pretty good.

I think Andy Weild also should be mentioned because I truly feel he has as much to do with drafting as the Kahn.

The Kahn pulls the trigger and makes the deals so he is actually a step up from Andy.

EDIT: Andy is better talent / needs ability, player evaluation type stuff.




Salute the nation
 
Last edited:
I think you put a lot of work into this and it sure shows in the original post that Kahn has been doing a pretty good job to date.

Things can be argued in many ways, but if the same criteria has been applied to all 32 teams, then it is a legit stat.

Remember the Kahn sat out his first draft because of Colbert being kept on… ( I think that had more to do with coach tomlin).


Thanks for all your great post(s) and insight slash, appreciate yaz…!!!




Salute the nation
I know you know this about me but some don’t.

When I evaluate something anything as a project I take away any opinion before I go into it. As with Omar I didn’t predetermine he was good or bad. Nor did I say to myself if he was bad then I would still stay the course that he was good or vice versa.

If he stunk I would simply have said it wasn’t pretty we need better.

I was locked into Howard it took one preseason for me to cool my breaks. Well documented I don’t care for Rudolph. But if Rudolph is the better option over Howard? Bye Will.

I always will be about team first my opinion second.

For me Omar has started off pretty decent. I like that we aren’t Peterson our free agent approach. That out of 32 teams our team is drafting starters at a pretty good ratio in an NFL comparison.

That pendulum could change down the road and that would be fine too. Then I would want change.

This is what have you done for me lately league, i think the majority of us really are simplistic in our wants.

Be competitive, sprinkle in some playoff wins , and show some hope for more.

That is a good base want. Of course then there is additional wants a championship game, a SB visit, a win. Show us at least a sound base. That isn’t spoiled, that isn’t unreasonable.

Just win !
 
Tied 5th out of 32, that is pretty good.

I think Andy Weild also should be mentioned because I truly feel he has as much to do with drafting as the Kahn.

The Kahn pulls the trigger and makes the deals so he is actually a step up from Andy.

EDIT: Andy is better talent / needs ability, player evaluation type stuff.




Salute the nation
Oh definitely. Andy was brought aboard and given a decent title they know he can evaluate. I love his trenches influence..
 
Not an ouchie for Omar, an ouchie for Tombert sure.
Never a losing season, greatest coach everrrr.....

Overall, I'd give the Khan Man a C.
 
Never a losing season, greatest coach everrrr.....

Overall, I'd give the Khan Man a C.
I think he is a B but we are talking one grade difference here. 👏
 
Was the formula I chose not to take credit if they started somewhere else and each team was evaluated with that same approach. I obviously know that it can be shared or tilted towards the second or third team. Etc.

That would have needed a lot more deciphering on a person to person basis.

Wasn’t really gluing into calling him something.. was more glued into an approach that could compare all the teams in regards to one aspect..
I know.. i was just poking the bear out of boredom, lol
 
Top