Worst Free Agent Signings.....

[Chicoman]

So who was the worst Steelers Free Agent signing?

 

[slashsteel]

So who was the worst Steelers Free Agent signing?

Blount.................

 

[mightyguru]

Mahan. How that guy was in the NFL baffles me...but apparently encouraged our braintrust...fart.

 

[steelermania]

Still has to be Graham, because as bad as those other guys are, none were actually given the keys to the team. There is no way to hide a qb as bad as Graham was. He lost his job to Kordell, and it was legitimate. Kordell took his job on merit. Think about that.

 

[Phinnster]

Can I pick all six?

 

[Shane Falco]

Staley was never the same after Suggs punched his hamstring. Up to that point in the season I beleive he was the teams leading rusher.
Didn't Mahan play in Super Bowl XL?

 

[Chicoman]

Staley was never the same after Suggs punched his hamstring. Up to that point in the season I beleive he was the teams leading rusher.
Didn't Mahan play in Super Bowl XL?

No the Steelers Center in Super Bowl XL was Jeff Hartings.

 

[GMC]

Definitely Mahan.

 

[Shane Falco]

Ah, thanks for the correction, I do remember him being on the line that year

 

[freak]

cam thomas

 

[SteelerSask2]

Mike Mitchell blows, but I kinda think that he at least in part couldn't work in tandem with Troy. He might be more salvageable with another Safety next year. That said, I hate the guy. He took so many stupid penalties and literally made no big plays to speak of. You would think a safety that is on the field for 17 games, might be in positon for an overthrow or a deflected pass, or jar a ball loose or something. I have no specific recollection of him making a play all year.

 

[Big Ben Rules]

CB Donnell Woolford sucked

 

[Steeltime]

Mitchell.

He was signed to be an improvement over Ryan Clark, and was to be an important part of what could have been a damn good team. He blew chunks ... and as others pointed out, he made exactly zero plays the entire season.

Zero.

No interceptions, no broken-up passes, no forced fumbles, no nothing.

 

[SteelerFan448]

It was a virtual tie between Mahan and Mitchell.

Mahan fit the bill of a transition to a soft offense with no philosophy while Mitchell was an actual big-money signing and had virtual nothing to show for it. Typically I like to give guys more than one year before making such a judgement, but I saw nothing to give me any hope.

 

[Confluence]

It was a virtual tie between Mahan and Mitchell.

Mahan fit the bill of a transition to a soft offense with no philosophy while Mitchell was an actual big-money signing and had virtual nothing to show for it. Typically I like to give guys more than one year before making such a judgement, but I saw nothing to give me any hope.

Mitchell was really good at late hits earlier in the season. Got a fistful of flags.

 

[Chicoman]

Mitchell was really good at late hits earlier in the season. Got a fistful of flags.

LOL Now that's funny! I needed a good laff today.

 

[scstillerfan]

CB Donnell Woolford sucked

This. Not even close.