How do the Browns NOT get somebody like Luck? I mean eventually?
Tim Couch over Donovan McNabb and Daunte Culpepper.
Courtney Brown over LaVarr Arrington (I know not a QB, but shows the decision making)
Gerrard Warren over LaDanian Tomlinson, Richard Seymore, Marcus Stroud (again decision making)
William Green in the first round (2002)
Jeff Faine when McGahee, Dallas Clark, and Larry Johnson still on the board
Kellen Winslow over Ben Roethlisberger, Vince Wilfork, Steven Jackson, etc. That draft was LOADED with talent.
Braylon Edwards over DeMarcus Ware, Shawn Merriman, Derrick Johnson, Aaron Rogers, Roddy White... Let that sink in, they took BRAYLON EDWARDS over AARON ROGERS!!!
Kamerion Wimbley over Antonio Cromartie, Jonathan Joseph, Nick Mangold
Joe Thomas in 2007 might be their only smart pick in the last 15 years
2008 they didn't make a pick until the fourth round.
Alex Mack wasn't a horrible choice, not much else on the board for them or anyone.... bad draft all around.
Joe Haden. Solid player, but there was Jason Pierre-Paul, Demaryius Thomas, Dez Bryant on the board as well.
Phil Taylor
Trent Richardson (and they traded UP for him) with Ryan Tannehill, Luke Kuechly on the board in the first, and in the second round took Mitchell Schwartz over Cordy Glenn, Alshon Jeffery, Bobby Wagner, Russell Wilson
The 13-14 drafts are too early to judge for them, but you can question their decision to trade back into the first for Johnny when he was clearly falling out of the first round all together. Their last five drafts have been much better, but if our last 15 drafts looked like theirs, this place would explode. Just look at the threads we currently have with our 2008-09 drafts coming up constantly. Fact is, their scouting dept is not that good, their FO made questionable decisions, ESPECIALLY in the first round. They have invested heavily in the secondary as of late, and their DL is solid, they have quality WR's... but still no QB.
Even their FA signings for QB's make you scratch your head.