• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

It’s still early....but which player currently headed to FA should be kept?

Ike Kelly

P-38L Fan
Member
Contributor
Joined
Apr 18, 2014
Messages
4,070
Reaction score
5,679
Points
113
We’ve got aplenty 2021 FAs on the roster right now, JuJu, Bud, Feiler, Conner, Banner, Hilton, Sutton are the prime players (4-5 starters!)

It’s hard to handicap what kind of room, cap wise, Pitt will have with all the uncertainty regarding COVID. But, What are your prognostications and why?


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
Toughest choices ever! JuJu, Bud, Feiler, Conner, Banner, Hilton, Sutton are the prime players (4-5 starters!)

Conner is Mr Pittsburgh. I'd love to retain him in a $4-6M capacity, but he's probably going to leave for more money.

JuJu is the same. $8-12M would be a steal for his services, but he's probably going to get $14-16M on the open market. He's the tag and trade option if you want high draft picks since he's so marketable. If he walks the walk and makes millions with his Littsburg clothing line, it's a no brainer to drop some pay to the squad since he can supplement his income with his brand. Still very expensive when the Steelers a loaded w/ young WR talent.

Bud is gone. We couldn't afford him this year, but thankfully he played his tag. He'd be another tag and trade option if he shows he can be productive 2 years in a row.

Banner and Feiler are my top resigns. Banner will be cheap coming off a season ending injury. Feiler will be cheaper since he's a G now instead of a T. Very signable guys.

Now I think the Hilton vs Sutton is an either or, since they are both nickel corners. Do you want the playmaker who will probably be more expensive to resign in Hilton, or do you want Youth and diversity, a guy who still plays ST, as well as Dime corner and dollar safety and can still backup the edge corners. When you lay it out like that, I take Sutton over one of my favorite players in Hilton.
 
We’ve got aplenty 2021 FAs on the roster right now, JuJu, Bud, Feiler, Conner, Banner, Hilton, Sutton are the prime players (4-5 starters!)

It’s hard to handicap what kind of room, cap wise, Pitt will have with all the uncertainty regarding COVID. But, What are your prognostications and why?


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app

JuJu (sign), Bud (PAY THAT MAN, as much as I'd love to see him stay, it can't happen. 3rd round comp pick for him leaving), Feiler (should have signed him long term before the season), Conner (let him walk), Banner (should be cheap), Hilton (walk free agent), Sutton (keep)
 
I see all a possibility of return outside of Bud. I would resign AV simply because Banner will be an injury risk. And LT isn't an easy replace. Is he not a FA ? don't see him mentioned...

Sent from my moto g(7) power using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
Last edited:
I think we have several categories of prices here. When prioritizing the players, I'm looking purely at value for the team in terms of importance and difficulty to replace.

Huge Contract

1. Bud Dupree - I like JuJu as a player better than Bud, but Bud is a tougher player to replace. He plays all phases of defense pretty well and is nice player to have across from Watt.

2. JuJu - I want to see him locked up to a long-term deal, yet I think wide receiver is the easier position to replace and the Steelers have three young guys behind him.

Big Contract

1. Mike Hilton - You need three starters at cornerback and Hilton is very good at what he does. He may be one of the top blitzing DBs in the league. With that said, I think we may overvalue him a bit here.

2. James Conner - One of my favorite guys on the team, I personally have him at 1. However, he plays a position you don't pay big money. When healthy, he's still the team's best option and I don't think he'll command a ton on the open market with his injury history.

3. Matt Feiler - You don't want to see too much turnover along the offensive line, but if Dotson can step up next year and the Steelers can roll with him and DeCastro, Feiler's importance is low on the list.

4. Alejandro Villanueva - Play has slipped a bit and is 32. I don't think he plays at a high level deep into his 30s like some tackles do, though replacing your LT is always tough.

Low-Moderate Contract

1. Tyson Alualu - He's played like a former first-round pick since joining the Steelers. Very valuable asset to the defensive line and should come at a fair price.

2. Cam Sutton - It'll either be Hilton or Sutton. They both have their strengths and I like Sutton's size. to keep him they'll need to give Sutton a nice bump in salary. He'll be cheaper than Hilton, but probably less versatile.

3. Zach Banner - Not enough snaps as a starter and coming off a major injury should make this an easy signing. Okorafor's play will factor in as they may want him as the RT of the future or maybe they'll feel like he can move to the left side and move on from AV. They may also decide Feiler is a better option. Either way, Banner should be affordable on a one-year deal.
 
We’ve got aplenty 2021 FAs on the roster right now, JuJu, Bud, Feiler, Conner, Banner, Hilton, Sutton are the prime players (4-5 starters!)

It’s hard to handicap what kind of room, cap wise, Pitt will have with all the uncertainty regarding COVID. But, What are your prognostications and why?


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app

I would keep Bud, JuJu, Hilton for sure......I know most say Bud will be gone, but if we break up Bud / Watt its really hurting 2 positions. We pay one big contract to lock up 2 very important spots. I know our Oline is bad, but we need to invest heavily in the draft there and sign who we can for depth.
 
I can't see them keeping Bud. He will be very expensive and there's no way they can pay Bud and TJ and Bush will need a new contract too in a couple years. So far Highsmith looks like a player. They don't need a pro bowler opposite TJ. They just need a solid player.

I'm still not convinced Bud is great on his own. Watt, Heyward, and Tuitt command a lot of attention.

They only way they keep JuJu is if James Washington disappoints and Claypool as well. Claypool has shown he can make plays downfield but how is he at running routes? If Dionte keeps getting injured and Washington continues to be decent but not great and Claypool struggles to run routes other than verticals, then they will keep JuJu. But i don't think that will happen. I think Dionte will prove himself to be a #1. Washington will be a reliable #2 and Claypool will show enough to be at least a #3 or role playing deep threat. JuJu will be too expensive to keep with other young talent on the roster
 
I think we have several categories of prices here. When prioritizing the players, I'm looking purely at value for the team in terms of importance and difficulty to replace.

Huge Contract

1. Bud Dupree - I like JuJu as a player better than Bud, but Bud is a tougher player to replace. He plays all phases of defense pretty well and is nice player to have across from Watt.

2. JuJu - I want to see him locked up to a long-term deal, yet I think wide receiver is the easier position to replace and the Steelers have three young guys behind him.

Big Contract

1. Mike Hilton - You need three starters at cornerback and Hilton is very good at what he does. He may be one of the top blitzing DBs in the league. With that said, I think we may overvalue him a bit here.

2. James Conner - One of my favorite guys on the team, I personally have him at 1. However, he plays a position you don't pay big money. When healthy, he's still the team's best option and I don't think he'll command a ton on the open market with his injury history.

3. Matt Feiler - You don't want to see too much turnover along the offensive line, but if Dotson can step up next year and the Steelers can roll with him and DeCastro, Feiler's importance is low on the list.

4. Alejandro Villanueva - Play has slipped a bit and is 32. I don't think he plays at a high level deep into his 30s like some tackles do, though replacing your LT is always tough.

Low-Moderate Contract

1. Tyson Alualu - He's played like a former first-round pick since joining the Steelers. Very valuable asset to the defensive line and should come at a fair price.

2. Cam Sutton - It'll either be Hilton or Sutton. They both have their strengths and I like Sutton's size. to keep him they'll need to give Sutton a nice bump in salary. He'll be cheaper than Hilton, but probably less versatile.

3. Zach Banner - Not enough snaps as a starter and coming off a major injury should make this an easy signing. Okorafor's play will factor in as they may want him as the RT of the future or maybe they'll feel like he can move to the left side and move on from AV. They may also decide Feiler is a better option. Either way, Banner should be affordable on a one-year deal.

Nice work.
Before the season I would have said Feiler, Banner and Sutton were the keeps.
Now, I believe Dotson can take over for Feiler. Banner will be back on the cheap. Hilton is very good but will make more $$$ than we can afford, so keep Sutton.
Bud will get PAID, and deservedly so. Conner just can't stay healthy. AV will probably retire and start working a vaccine for the next pandemic.
Whick leads me to JuJu.While our young WR's are good, JuJu makes this WR corp special. He gets the tough catches, breaks tackles and shows up in big moments.
He also has a great connection with #7. While I realize we won't have very much $$$ to throw around, we should be able to get him for 16-17mil per season. Yes, that's a lot.
But it's the rate at which he will garner on the open market. I'm sure we could structure something to keep his first year cap hit at 5-7mil.

Big question is what to do at TE? VM is 99% gone. What do you do with Ebron. He has injected the position with some unusual separation ability and RAC.
However, is it worth 6mil? Maybe you let him go as well and bring in a stop gap while drafting a TE in rds 1 or 2. Seems to be a decent crop next year.

In the draft, grab another LT, TE and RB.
 
I would keep Bud, JuJu, Hilton for sure......I know most say Bud will be gone, but if we break up Bud / Watt its really hurting 2 positions. We pay one big contract to lock up 2 very important spots. I know our Oline is bad, but we need to invest heavily in the draft there and sign who we can for depth.

Not trying to be a turd here...but where will we get the money to keep Bud, JuJu and Hilton?
We will be severely CAP-hampered due to COVID. You are looking at roughly 40mil per year combined there.
 
Not trying to be a turd here...but where will we get the money to keep Bud, JuJu and Hilton?
We will be severely CAP-hampered due to COVID. You are looking at roughly 40mil per year combined there.

Hard to say what cap will be and i know it will be tough. We saw what our secondary looks like without a pass rush. If we take Dupree away TJ will be getting doubled every play and the D will be exposed. Steelers have done very well with the cap will be interesting to see what they come up with
 
extend watt ben 2 yr same with pouncey it will free up more money
JUJU loves being in Pitt I think he will think hard before taking 4-6 mill to play with some medicore QB unless Green bay ponies up cash, can see houston ready to show him 14-18 mill based on what Anderson got.
Hilton gotta find a way to keep him Banner as well Fielier I like but I love what I saw of Dotson and think he can easily replace Matt
put transition tag on Bud Tyson is a keeper great versatility havent seen them using Worsmsley enough to determine if he could start at NT and play heavy sub rotating reps Buggs is the top sub DL as of now
Again ask haden vance vince to take paycuts.
 
Last edited:
extend watt ben 2 yr same with pouncey it will free up more money
JUJU loves being in Pitt I think he will think hard before taking 4-6 mill to play with some medicore QB unless Green bay ponies up cash, can see houston ready to show him 14-18 mill based on what Anderson got.
Hilton gotta find a way to keep him Banner as well Fielier I like but I love what I saw of Dotson and think he can easily replace Matt
put transition tag on Bud Tyson is a keeper great versatility havent seen them using Worsmsley enough to determine if he could start at NT and play heavy sub rotating reps Buggs is the top sub DL as of now
Again ask haden vance vince to take paycuts.

Sounds good...but, most in the know are estimating that the 2021 cap will come in around 175 mil, which is 25 mil less than this year.

We will have to do some serious restructuring just to get to compliance.
 
All depends Conner willingness to take less 3-4 per year 2-3 years fine more than 4 mill per year than pass draft Harris out of Bama. offer him 3 years 14 mill incentive laced where gamples played and TD's per season receptions are in bonus. I dont want to spend a rnd 1 pick on RB or trade out to rnd 2 for Harris, I want our rnd 1 pick to be OT to replace Big Al.
 
Sounds good...but, most in the know are estimating that the 2021 cap will come in around 175 mil, which is 25 mil less than this year.

We will have to do some serious restructuring just to get to compliance.

It’s true that the 2021 cap is estimated to be approximately $175 mil. However, as they did after the 2019 season concluded, he NFLPA and NFL worked a amendment to the 2020 season cap due to the economic barrier COVID was bringing to the NHL, NBA and MLB. It’s been mentioned by both sides that a similar agreement will be made at the end of the 2020 season to keep the cap at least at the 2020 number. Teams don’t want to cut the large contracts of their best players to fit under a inaccurate cap. Additionally they league doesn’t want a huge volume of established vets on the market because of a situation that was not in their control.

Cope has the right idea though, a “limited” uncapped year may be a better option. Having vested veteran players costing a % of their actual cap charge.


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
JuJu...because he is the closest thing we got to a #1 receiver at the moment..
 
Given the teams ability to develop O line talent, I wouildnt worry so much about feiler. I would make all the aforementioned players reasonable offers ,, as able.

However. This team has had to trade / sign free agent DB's. We haven't been able to draft great DB talent. If im tombert, im trying like hell to keep mike Hilton.



Bud is too expensive and we cant pay both of those guys (tj)

I like conner but I don't think he will light the world on fire with offers. I just don't. I think we're able to keep him.
 
Nice analysis by SF448. Added my thoughts to his...

1. Bud Dupree - I like JuJu as a player better than Bud, but Bud is a tougher player to replace. He plays all phases of defense pretty well and is nice player to have across from Watt.
I'd like to keep Bud but don't think we can afford him. I think he tests the market and finds a taker willing to cash him out. Steelers drafted Highsmith as a replacement and with TJs contract coming up I sadly see Bud moving on.

2. JuJu - I want to see him locked up to a long-term deal, yet I think wide receiver is the easier position to replace and the Steelers have three young guys behind him.
Totally agree with your thinking here. JuJu would have to give us a major hometown discount in order to stay.


1. Mike Hilton - You need three starters at cornerback and Hilton is very good at what he does. He may be one of the top blitzing DBs in the league. With that said, I think we may overvalue him a bit here.
Again I agree. Unless he gets a serious offer that prices us out of the market, Hilton fits very well with the defensive scheme and should be kept.

2. James Conner - One of my favorite guys on the team, I personally have him at 1. However, he plays a position you don't pay big money. When healthy, he's still the team's best option and I don't think he'll command a ton on the open market with his injury history.
Agreed. RBs are pretty cheap and easily replaced. He's a valuable piece that could probably be kept for a reasonable contract.

3. Matt Feiler - You don't want to see too much turnover along the offensive line, but if Dotson can step up next year and the Steelers can roll with him and DeCastro, Feiler's importance is low on the list.
Dotson looked great in limited action. Feiler is good but doesn't appear to be anything special to me. Depth on the line is important but how long can you keep Dotson on the bench? I'd let Feiler walk.

4. Alejandro Villanueva - Play has slipped a bit and is 32. I don't think he plays at a high level deep into his 30s like some tackles do, though replacing your LT is always tough.
I think AV is ready to retire. I really don't see him moving to another team so if he decides to keep playing I think it will be for us.

Low-Moderate Contract

1. Tyson Alualu - He's played like a former first-round pick since joining the Steelers. Very valuable asset to the defensive line and should come at a fair price.
Agree haven't missed the Grave Digger at all.

2. Cam Sutton - It'll either be Hilton or Sutton. They both have their strengths and I like Sutton's size. to keep him they'll need to give Sutton a nice bump in salary. He'll be cheaper than Hilton, but probably less versatile.
I think we keep both. Haden is getting up in years and Sutton is a very versatile defender.

3. Zach Banner - Not enough snaps as a starter and coming off a major injury should make this an easy signing. Okorafor's play will factor in as they may want him as the RT of the future or maybe they'll feel like he can move to the left side and move on from AV. They may also decide Feiler is a better option. Either way, Banner should be affordable on a one-year deal.
Hoping that Banner and Chuks can be mainstays at OT in the near future. Keep him.
 
We’ve got aplenty 2021 FAs on the roster right now, JuJu, Bud, Feiler, Conner, Banner, Hilton, Sutton are the prime players (4-5 starters!)

It’s hard to handicap what kind of room, cap wise, Pitt will have with all the uncertainty regarding COVID. But, What are your prognostications and why?


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app
Let's assume that next season's cap gets readjusted to 200M, with that premise the Steelers are currently about 2,6M above it already without said free agents.

About 9,6M from this season rolls over to the next and the team truly is 7M below the new cap. Now comes the negotiation time with current contracts:

- Ben has a 44M cap hit, yeap, you read that correctly. So he gets extended one or two seasons and the money rolls to future seasons, let's say it frees up 10M.

- pouncey has a 14,5M cap hit, if Ben stays he stays so rinse and repeat and you get 5M in cap space approx

- Stephon Tuitt has almost a 15M cap hit, he becomes an UFA after 2022 and 30 years old, if he produces this season I can see an extension that lowers next season hit, again let's say it saves 5M

-DeCastro: look Tuitt above, but a couple years older, extend and save 5M

Now comes the tough choices:
- Haden has a cap hit of 15,5M and a dead cap of 2,9M do cutting him would save 12,6M. Given his age either he signs a friendly extension or he gets cut. With 32 years old next season the Steelers have good leverage to work an extension and lower his cap hit 5M, cutting him opens another big hole that won't be addresed with little money and is a bet that won't be made in Ben's final run years.

- vince is playing lights out but next season is his last on his current contract, 7M cap hit, 3M dead cap and he will be 32 years old in 2022. He either resigns a friendly contract that lowers the cap a couple of millions or he might be gone. I bet he stays and lowers his cap hit by 2M.

- McDonald has a cap hit of 7,9M and a dead cap of 2,75M. He gets cut saving a little over 5M. The team needs to draft a TE early next draft to complement Ebron.

So after all this ifs and assumptions the team saves 37M, add 7M from this years roll over and that's almost 45M available to go free agent shopping.

- Juju has to be kept, DJ is fragile and Washington might be a decent #2 but I don't see a high ceiling (he might be trade bait for a late 2nd rounder or early 3rd) , 15M avg might work for both sides.

- Feiler, I'm not in love with what I have seen from him at LG, it might be that a readjustment period is needed but with Dotson showing his worth so early maybe the writing is in the wall for him. If he can be kept cheap and I mean 6M tops as he might compete with Banner for the RT spot as Chuks gets moved to LT and that takes us to...

- Villanueva, I think his best years are past him and the team won't be able to keep him at a high price tag, he either stays as backup vet or he might be gone

- James Conner, who doesn't root for the kid? He might be kept for 4M avg and be part of a RB rotation.

- Mike Hilton has earned every cent that goes his way next season and I hope they come from the Steelers, might 7M avg do it?

- Cam Sutton, jack of all trades. Would he accept a 4M avg contract? He'd be the main backup in all CB spots

- Banner was affected by injury unfortunately and he has to earn his payday next season, 4M to resign him.

That's already 40M and Bud Dupree hasn't been addressed yet so I don't see how can he be kept without severely killing all depth in the roster. There's a reason the team invested a 3rd rounder on a OLB and the good thing is that the kid is already showing some talent so the possibility to have an in house transition without losing too much talent on the field is possible. I just don't see the team able to draft a CB worth a sweat so better keep who you already have.

The Steelers would still need to go heavy early on on OLine and TE in the draft to complete the roster

Enviado desde mi Moto G (5) Plus mediante Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
We’ve got aplenty 2021 FAs on the roster right now, JuJu, Bud, Feiler, Conner, Banner, Hilton, Sutton are the prime players (4-5 starters!)

It’s hard to handicap what kind of room, cap wise, Pitt will have with all the uncertainty regarding COVID. But, What are your prognostications and why?


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app


I have seen this thread before. Going into to 2021 the Steelers are $17,112.571 over the cap.

https://overthecap.com/salary-cap/pittsburgh-steelers/

The cap which is currently $198.2 million may go down next year, with a floor set at $175 million.

Before we sign any free agents, we need to clean up over 17 million + make room for the rookies.

Translation we don't have the money to re-sign anyone decent. Let them go, I'll take the 3rd or 4th round comp pick from Ju-Ju, and Bud.

Losing Hilton and Feiler will hurt a bit, but it is what it is. We should be able to keep Banner
 
Blah blah blah cooch the Steelers will adjust and if they need a free agent they will go get one. Not buying Big Al will be a backup. He is either a starter here or elsewhere. Gloom and doom outlook with how this team handles the cap is just silly. Steelers will keep a good amount and again fill the rest through the draft and free agency. Business as usual.


Sent from my moto g(7) power using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
Last edited:
Let's assume that next season's cap gets readjusted to 200M, with that premise the Steelers are currently about 2,6M above it already without said free agents.

About 9,6M from this season rolls over to the next and the team truly is 7M below the new cap. Now comes the negotiation time with current contracts:

- Ben has a 44M cap hit, yeap, you read that correctly. So he gets extended one or two seasons and the money rolls to future seasons, let's say it frees up 10M.

- pouncey has a 14,5M cap hit, if Ben stays he stays so rinse and repeat and you get 5M in cap space approx

- Stephon Tuitt has almost a 15M cap hit, he becomes an UFA after 2022 and 30 years old, if he produces this season I can see an extension that lowers next season hit, again let's say it saves 5M

-DeCastro: look Tuitt above, but a couple years older, extend and save 5M

Now comes the tough choices:
- Haden has a cap hit of 15,5M and a dead cap of 2,9M do cutting him would save 12,6M. Given his age either he signs a friendly extension or he gets cut. With 32 years old next season the Steelers have good leverage to work an extension and lower his cap hit 5M, cutting him opens another big hole that won't be addresed with little money and is a bet that won't be made in Ben's final run years.

- vince is playing lights out but next season is his last on his current contract, 7M cap hit, 3M dead cap and he will be 32 years old in 2022. He either resigns a friendly contract that lowers the cap a couple of millions or he might be gone. I bet he stays and lowers his cap hit by 2M.

- McDonald has a cap hit of 7,9M and a dead cap of 2,75M. He gets cut saving a little over 5M. The team needs to draft a TE early next draft to complement Ebron.

So after all this ifs and assumptions the team saves 37M, add 7M from this years roll over and that's almost 45M available to go free agent shopping.

- Juju has to be kept, DJ is fragile and Washington might be a decent #2 but I don't see a high ceiling (he might be trade bait for a late 2nd rounder or early 3rd) , 15M avg might work for both sides.

- Feiler, I'm not in love with what I have seen from him at LG, it might be that a readjustment period is needed but with Dotson showing his worth so early maybe the writing is in the wall for him. If he can be kept cheap and I mean 6M tops as he might compete with Banner for the RT spot as Chuks gets moved to LT and that takes us to...

- Villanueva, I think his best years are past him and the team won't be able to keep him at a high price tag, he either stays as backup vet or he might be gone

- James Conner, who doesn't root for the kid? He might be kept for 4M avg and be part of a RB rotation.

- Mike Hilton has earned every cent that goes his way next season and I hope they come from the Steelers, might 7M avg do it?

- Cam Sutton, jack of all trades. Would he accept a 4M avg contract? He'd be the main backup in all CB spots

- Banner was affected by injury unfortunately and he has to earn his payday next season, 4M to resign him.

That's already 40M and Bud Dupree hasn't been addressed yet so I don't see how can he be kept without severely killing all depth in the roster. There's a reason the team invested a 3rd rounder on a OLB and the good thing is that the kid is already showing some talent so the possibility to have an in house transition without losing too much talent on the field is possible. I just don't see the team able to draft a CB worth a sweat so better keep who you already have.

The Steelers would still need to go heavy early on on OLine and TE in the draft to complete the roster

Enviado desde mi Moto G (5) Plus mediante Tapatalk

They can also tweak McDonald's contract too, cutting isn't the only option. Like your overall breakdown though.

Sent from my moto g(7) power using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
I have seen this thread before. Going into to 2021 the Steelers are $17,112.571 over the cap.

https://overthecap.com/salary-cap/pittsburgh-steelers/

The cap which is currently $198.2 million may go down next year, with a floor set at $175 million.

Before we sign any free agents, we need to clean up over 17 million + make room for the rookies.

Translation we don't have the money to re-sign anyone decent. Let them go, I'll take the 3rd or 4th round comp pick from Ju-Ju, and Bud.

Losing Hilton and Feiler will hurt a bit, but it is what it is. We should be able to keep Banner

Caw, caw, caw, caw......this and flapping wings = your posting. Sounds like Crows on a fence.

You are getting all your useless threads mixed up in your own head.

17 million for rookies? Sorry Dumb *** the league uses a slotted rookie scale now and have been for around a decade. 7 picks don’t cost 17 million on a single year cap.

Translation, pipe down. You don’t know jack. Shut your pie hole. The adults are talking.


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
I think we have several categories of prices here. When prioritizing the players, I'm looking purely at value for the team in terms of importance and difficulty to replace.

Huge Contract

1. Bud Dupree - I like JuJu as a player better than Bud, but Bud is a tougher player to replace. He plays all phases of defense pretty well and is nice player to have across from Watt.

2. JuJu - I want to see him locked up to a long-term deal, yet I think wide receiver is the easier position to replace and the Steelers have three young guys behind him.

Big Contract

1. Mike Hilton - You need three starters at cornerback and Hilton is very good at what he does. He may be one of the top blitzing DBs in the league. With that said, I think we may overvalue him a bit here.

2. James Conner - One of my favorite guys on the team, I personally have him at 1. However, he plays a position you don't pay big money. When healthy, he's still the team's best option and I don't think he'll command a ton on the open market with his injury history.

3. Matt Feiler - You don't want to see too much turnover along the offensive line, but if Dotson can step up next year and the Steelers can roll with him and DeCastro, Feiler's importance is low on the list.

4. Alejandro Villanueva - Play has slipped a bit and is 32. I don't think he plays at a high level deep into his 30s like some tackles do, though replacing your LT is always tough.

Low-Moderate Contract

1. Tyson Alualu - He's played like a former first-round pick since joining the Steelers. Very valuable asset to the defensive line and should come at a fair price.

2. Cam Sutton - It'll either be Hilton or Sutton. They both have their strengths and I like Sutton's size. to keep him they'll need to give Sutton a nice bump in salary. He'll be cheaper than Hilton, but probably less versatile.

3. Zach Banner - Not enough snaps as a starter and coming off a major injury should make this an easy signing. Okorafor's play will factor in as they may want him as the RT of the future or maybe they'll feel like he can move to the left side and move on from AV. They may also decide Feiler is a better option. Either way, Banner should be affordable on a one-year deal.



A good effort. Some minor disagreements.


Alualu is having a very good year. He might get a contract slightly below Hargrave is he keeps it up.


Villanueva is in decline as the left tackle, but he'd probably look much better at right tackle


Banner should be in his own tier. Not much more than NFL Minimum. He's only played one game as a starter and has been cut by more than one teams. With his injury, no other team will offer him say 4 million to above a year. At least think so. CHuck is much better, and no way could Banner play left tackle with CHuck staying at Tight Tack;e.


Either way, the Steelers NEED to draft a tackle in the draft early.


Now for reality, we are in cap space hell.


We can use the system to help reload.


I'll take a stab at compensatory picks under the caveat the Steelers sign 2-3 cheap free agents from other teams. What could the Steelers get in the form of compensation if they lose the following players in free agency?


My best guess:


Dupree- 3rd round comp pick
Ju-Ju - 4th round comp pick ( He's not standing out as he used to )
Hilton - 5th round comp pick, and I'd hate to lose him.
Feiler - 5th round comp pick
Villanueva - 5th round comp pick. He'd older
Conner - 6th round comp pick, he's a running back...
Alualu- 6th round comp pick
Sutton - 7th round comp pick
Banner - no comp pick
 
Top