Wait...Geno Smith (a previous starter - turn journeyman) turned his career around and has been absolutely ballin' this season.  Rudy got his shot to resurrect his career and he shined.
I think it is very fair to say that 'we know what Kenny brings to the team'.  If we haven't evaluated him in nearly two seasons of starts - something is drastically wrong.  Yeah, I know, we've got new coordinators on offense; but Kenny (and Mitch) force balls into coverage which result in INTs.  I've yet to see that in Rudy's game play...
He's definitely my #2 going into 2024, and that is depending on how he, if given the chance, to finish out the season...