Ben has to start beating Rogers and Brady before I put him in their category. Sorry.
This makes no sense. QBs don't compete against one another. Beat them how, head to head, relying on the team around him not to **** it up? In stats, where he neck-and-neck/better than them last year and is currently leading the league in YPA (regarded as one of the premier indicators of QB talent)?
Ben is 1-1 against the Rodgers Packers. He had his first 500 yard game against them in 2009 and then lost the SB with a hobbled Troy and no Pouncey.
Ben is 2-6 vs. the Brady Patriots:
1-1 as a rookie in 2004
0-1 in 2005, lost on game-ending FG
0-1 in 2007, undefeated Patriots team
0-1 2010
1-0 2011, the game we destroyed them but the final score ended 25-17
0-1 2013 Defense got hatefucked
0-1 2015
So is it Ben's fault that the defense has laid down against the Patriots most years? Ben's only game with more than 1 INT against the Patriots was the AFCCG. Outside of that he's had mostly great performances.