• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Another example of players just not being coached up.

From a very interesting article I read today about Sean McVay, I sooooo would love to see Tomlin replaced with a young coach like this:

Following the Week 4 win over the Vikings, Whitworth told reporters in the locker room that McVay and his staffers don’t coach football. They teach it. Every directive is coupled with a specific reasoning. “Everyone can, for lack of a better word, empathize with it,” Whitworth says. “It’s ‘OK, not only do I understand what to do, I understand why I would want to do it that way.’”

When an issue arises, players are able to voice their concerns to McVay, and one of two outcomes will follow. Either the coach will explain, in depth, why a concept is necessary, or he’ll brainstorm a way to change it to fit the player’s preference.

For all the bells and whistles adorning this offense, though, the Rams staff will tell you that the basic set of plays it has each week remains relatively static. McVay’s biggest advantage isn’t that he has a 1,000-page playbook for defenses to worry about; it’s that the fundamental set of plays the Rams rely on is built to accommodate one or two adjustments acutely aimed at attacking a specific defense. By the time a defense realizes how a concept differs from what it’s seen on tape, it’s too late. “That, to me, is the essence of football,” Whitworth says. “When you look at the rare teams, the rare NFL offenses, outside of special talent, the good ones are the ones where everything’s married to each other. Everything looks the same, but it’s completely different. That’s where teams get special and play to their potential.”

Cooper Kupp was telling Rich Eisen, that the Rams don't have a physical playbook, just a mental one.

https://www.theringer.com/nfl/2018/10/4/17936990/sean-mcvay-offensive-mind-los-angeles-rams
 
From a very interesting article I read today about Sean McVay, I sooooo would love to see Tomlin replaced with a young coach like this:

Following the Week 4 win over the Vikings, Whitworth told reporters in the locker room that McVay and his staffers don’t coach football. They teach it. Every directive is coupled with a specific reasoning. “Everyone can, for lack of a better word, empathize with it,” Whitworth says. “It’s ‘OK, not only do I understand what to do, I understand why I would want to do it that way.’”

When an issue arises, players are able to voice their concerns to McVay, and one of two outcomes will follow. Either the coach will explain, in depth, why a concept is necessary, or he’ll brainstorm a way to change it to fit the player’s preference.

For all the bells and whistles adorning this offense, though, the Rams staff will tell you that the basic set of plays it has each week remains relatively static. McVay’s biggest advantage isn’t that he has a 1,000-page playbook for defenses to worry about; it’s that the fundamental set of plays the Rams rely on is built to accommodate one or two adjustments acutely aimed at attacking a specific defense. By the time a defense realizes how a concept differs from what it’s seen on tape, it’s too late. “That, to me, is the essence of football,” Whitworth says. “When you look at the rare teams, the rare NFL offenses, outside of special talent, the good ones are the ones where everything’s married to each other. Everything looks the same, but it’s completely different. That’s where teams get special and play to their potential.”

Cooper Kupp was telling Rich Eisen, that the Rams don't have a physical playbook, just a mental one.

https://www.theringer.com/nfl/2018/10/4/17936990/sean-mcvay-offensive-mind-los-angeles-rams

Pfffft.... teaching players is overrated and doesn't hold a candle to dreaming up non-existent words and declaring to the world that Hell is about to be unleashed.
 
From a very interesting article I read today about Sean McVay, I sooooo would love to see Tomlin replaced with a young coach like this:

Following the Week 4 win over the Vikings, Whitworth told reporters in the locker room that McVay and his staffers don’t coach football. They teach it. Every directive is coupled with a specific reasoning. “Everyone can, for lack of a better word, empathize with it,” Whitworth says. “It’s ‘OK, not only do I understand what to do, I understand why I would want to do it that way.’”

When an issue arises, players are able to voice their concerns to McVay, and one of two outcomes will follow. Either the coach will explain, in depth, why a concept is necessary, or he’ll brainstorm a way to change it to fit the player’s preference.

For all the bells and whistles adorning this offense, though, the Rams staff will tell you that the basic set of plays it has each week remains relatively static. McVay’s biggest advantage isn’t that he has a 1,000-page playbook for defenses to worry about; it’s that the fundamental set of plays the Rams rely on is built to accommodate one or two adjustments acutely aimed at attacking a specific defense. By the time a defense realizes how a concept differs from what it’s seen on tape, it’s too late. “That, to me, is the essence of football,” Whitworth says. “When you look at the rare teams, the rare NFL offenses, outside of special talent, the good ones are the ones where everything’s married to each other. Everything looks the same, but it’s completely different. That’s where teams get special and play to their potential.”

Cooper Kupp was telling Rich Eisen, that the Rams don't have a physical playbook, just a mental one.

https://www.theringer.com/nfl/2018/10/4/17936990/sean-mcvay-offensive-mind-los-angeles-rams

Oh yeah ?

Tomlin has his really cool glasses and some really cool cliches .

And and a really cool stare when things are going south.

And he will make his version of Tampa blew work,

you just just wait for it.

And wait for it


and

wait

for


it
 
Matthew Thomas can probably start any position at LB'er on the Steelers roster and do a better job than whoever is filling that position currently. Yes even TJ Watt!

**** I could beat out Bud Dupree at ROLB.
 
Pfffft.... teaching players is overrated and doesn't hold a candle to dreaming up non-existent words and declaring to the world that Hell is about to be unleashed.

These are professionals, why would they need taught?
 
All you need to know about Tomlin as a teacher of the game is the Steelers inability to draft and develop defensive backs under him, considering he established himself in the league as a DB coach.

The guy's useless.
 
My point was Harrison was cut numerous times by multiple teams. Was sent to Europe to play. Then cut again. He couldn't stick on a team. I'm talking about the entire 53 man roster. Not the players that were starting. He wasn't even a back up of a back up. Some players just need time. Would I rather they start this kid over the crap we have playing now? Sure. The coaches seem to think he isn't ready. Hasn't even gotten a defensive snap yet I believe. A shame really.

I don't think any rookie is ready to play on this version of the Steeler defense not because they are good (we know they are not good right now), but because there seems to be very little leadership on the field, lining up incorrectly, substituting incorrectly, coaching mistakes, a rookie on this defense doesn't have anyone to look to for information and, as you are seeing, Edmunds is struggling at times and at other times he looks good. The veterans really need to get a grip on this defense and at least clean up the mental mistakes.

Papillon
 
Matthew Thomas can probably start any position at LB'er on the Steelers roster and do a better job than whoever is filling that position currently. Yes even TJ Watt!

**** I could beat out Bud Dupree at ROLB.



The ONLY problem is Mathew would still be coached by the coaches the original starters are being coached by. He'd have to fall into their same assignments and defensive scheme................................. Afraid the end result would end up in insufficient play. I like Thomas greatly and he would be better yes but ultimately doomed.





Salute the nation
 
Top