So what do we want from a 7th round draft pick, selected #230 overall? How about these qualities:
- Positional versatility. Check
- Elite physical tools. (Check out his 40 and 3-cone times) Check
- Potential special teams contributor. Check
- Willingness, heart, ability to take and deliver punishment. Check
- Production in college. Check
- Performed on a big stage. (Anybody who thinks Army-Navy is not big stage can leave now) Check
Heidenreich ran the 5th fastest time in the 40 for RB's at the combine, the 6th best vertical, and an elite 3-cone of 6.55 seconds. Great footwork, very good hands. You want a 7th round pick from a school that did not have the toughest schedule to show he is much better than the competition, meaning his skill level was above that competition. In 2025, Heidenreich had 941 receiving yards, 18.5 YPC, 6 TD's (in an offense that ran the ball about 70% of the time) and 499 rushing yards, 6.5 YPA, 6 TD's so yes, he dominated the competition.
Against Notre Dame, Navy attempted 8 passes, completed 3. Heidenreich had two of the three team receptions. He ran the ball once for 15 yards. Navy was outclassed but the guy who made plays when given a chance was Heidenreich. Against Cincinnati in the Liberty Bowl, Heidenreich ran the ball 10 times for 64 yards, had 5 catches for 64 yards and a TD. Navy had 349 yards of total offense, Heidenreich had 128 of those yards, or 37% of their offense.
That's a good 7th round pick so I think we can put to rest the "Oh, they selected him because he's local" theme. They selected him because he is about as good a 7th round pick as is available.*
*With their 7th round pick, the Colts selected a different running back Seth McGowan. He had some good combine results, including a 4.49 40 and really good vertical. Less production in college with limited receiving numbers. Oh, yeah, and he was arrested for armed robbery and assault and battery in 2021 and I guess some may view that as a negative but that's just kids being kids.