• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Best Players to NEVER Play in the Super Bowl

CoolieMan

Most Intelligent Poster
Moderator
Forefather
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
19,670
Reaction score
36,250
Points
113
Location
Heaven on Earth
So the NFL Network did their top 10 list of the best players to never play in the Super Bowl...it is as follows

10 Sterling Sharpe
9 Randall Cunningham
Dan Diordorf
LaDamian Tomlinson
John Randle
Eric Dickerson
Chris Carter
3 Tony Gonzales
2 Dan Fouts
1 Barry Sanders

not sure of the order except the top 3....

Not real sure how Earl Campbell was left off that list....who else do you think should have or could have made the list?
 
  • Like
Reactions: MTC
Another list reminds us of OJ, Dickerson, Sayers, Campbell, Butkus, and Deacon Jones.
 
Sterling Sharpe probably shouldn't be on there, he had a very good 3 year stretch from like 93-95 or something. I'm assuming this is during the Super Bowl era so Jim Brown just missed out.
I'm assuming this is retired players, because if not, how isn't AB on there, everyone says he's first ballot HOF'er and the best ever to play WR.
 
Sterling Sharpe probably shouldn't be on there, he had a very good 3 year stretch from like 93-95 or something. I'm assuming this is during the Super Bowl era so Jim Brown just missed out.
I'm assuming this is retired players, because if not, how isn't AB on there, everyone says he's first ballot HOF'er and the best ever to play WR.

AB is with the Raiders so it is safe to put him on the list unless he goes to another team in the future.
 
I'm assuming this is retired players, because if not, how isn't AB on there, everyone says he's first ballot HOF'er and the best ever to play WR.

Apparently, Ryan Shazier doesn't even think he's the best playing right now:

Ryan Shazier@RyanShazier

Ryan Shazier Retweeted ProFootballTalk
As he should be ����

@ProFootballTalk
Report: Saints are “comfortable” making Michael Thomas the highest-paid receiver in the game, and soon https://wp.me/p14QSB-b0Ie
8:04 PM - 18 Jun 2019 from Fox Chapel, PA
 
Ken Houston and Moon too..............
 
Wasn't it his rookie season, too? Or was it his sophomore season? Imagine going that early and then never making it again. That's rough.
 
Wasn't it his rookie season, too? Or was it his sophomore season? Imagine going that early and then never making it again. That's rough.

think 2nd and beat us to go to the SB....
 
Top