• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

The moves the team should strongly consider:

slashsteel

Thank you for everything Franco, R I P.
Contributor
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
42,784
Reaction score
54,710
Points
113
Location
Pittsburgh
With RT and WR having depth concerns these are the moves I would make:

* Trade Broderick Jones. Being a young athletic LT I think the team would still garnish interest. Say for a 4th or 5th.

* Trade for Darius Slayton. I hear the G-men might be willing to move on with a youth movement and salary figuring in. It would only take one Steelers restructure to free up room.

* Bring in a RT for competition/ depth. I would look at acquiring Delmar "DJ" Glaze or Blake Fisher. Or another RT capable.

* If one of the corners get PUP’d then I would bring in one more corner off final cuts.

For me this is Aaron’s last season so you fortify the two potential weaknesses. You don’t roll the dice and box yourself into having to depend on rookies or fringe roster players at two crucial positions.
 
Nobody's giving up a 4th or 5th for Jones after what he's put on tape. Move on from this bust.
The left tackle position is always in high demand. I would be surprised if they couldn’t get a 5th for him. He has starter experience and is young.
 
Nobody's giving up a 4th or 5th for Jones after what he's put on tape. Move on from this bust.



You have to shop before you cut.

The flip side is……… other teams know he’s getting cut and will show patience till then.

Your only chance is a shot in the dark “cheap” offer, take it as a little bit of something beats a whole lot of nothing.




Salute the nation
 
Nobody's giving up a 4th or 5th for Jones after what he's put on tape. Move on from this bust.
A bust coming off of spinal fusion surgery on top of it. I'm sure NFL GMs would be lining up to throw away a fourth round pick for this guy. :rolleyes:
 
A bust coming off of spinal fusion surgery on top of it. I'm sure NFL GMs would be lining up to throw away a fourth round pick for this guy. :rolleyes:
Not a fourth, but OLmen are really in need across the league and he has years of starting experience..

Also everyone knows transitioning to a whole new system and techniques on the OL can lead to across tge board bad play for a period early in the process..

So someone may give something for him... remember how Dan moore got way more than we thought in UFA and guys like Greene got traded because the league has a shortage of experianced big men
 
I see both sides to this but I think it’s going to be whatever they can get for him.
Man have we taken a nose dive drafting number one players over the past dozen years. Far too many busts with number ones not receiving second contracts or even getting their fifth year options picked up. You simply cannot build top tier teams drafting like this.
Man this crap goes back to Artie Burns,Jarvis Jones, Devin Bush, Najee Harris, Kenny Pickett, Broderick Jones.
That’s six different drafts with busts at the first round pick. Not good!
 
Not a fourth, but OLmen are really in need across the league and he has years of starting experience..

Also everyone knows transitioning to a whole new system and techniques on the OL can lead to across tge board bad play for a period early in the process..
So someone may give something for him...
Don't hold your breath.
remember how Dan moore got way more than we thought in UFA and guys like Greene got traded because the league has a shortage of experianced big men
Dan Moore started 16 or 17 games every season for 4 years straight out of the chute, and never had a serious injury issue. Not a similar situation. True, the Steelers somehow managed to get a sixth round pick for Kendrick Green...and he's gone on to start four games in the three years since, bouncing around practice squads.

Maybe there's a GM out there stupid enough to trade for Jones, too. I doubt it.
 
Not a fourth, but OLmen are really in need across the league and he has years of starting experience..

Also everyone knows transitioning to a whole new system and techniques on the OL can lead to across tge board bad play for a period early in the process..

So someone may give something for him... remember how Dan moore got way more than we thought in UFA and guys like Greene got traded because the league has a shortage of experianced big men
Spoken for common sense. 👏😆
 
No way I would trade Jones for a 5rh. He is still coming back from injury. If anything ir him and give him time to get back to 100%
They could put him on the PUP I think after initially making the roster if I remember correctly.
 
Don't hold your breath.

Dan Moore started 16 or 17 games every season for 4 years straight out of the chute, and never had a serious injury issue. Not a similar situation. True, the Steelers somehow managed to get a sixth round pick for Kendrick Green...and he's gone on to start four games in the three years since, bouncing around practice squads.

Maybe there's a GM out there stupid enough to trade for Jones, too. I doubt it.
There was a GM that gave up too much for Claypool. Plenty of other GMs that gave up too much stock. Again it is a premium position with a higher demand than availability.

Broderick has been cleared and is back to playing. Not unreasonable that that could get you a fifth we aren’t talking first or second rounder. 5th rounders bust out all the time.
 
I see both sides to this but I think it’s going to be whatever they can get for him.
Man have we taken a nose dive drafting number one players over the past dozen years. Far too many busts with number ones not receiving second contracts or even getting their fifth year options picked up. You simply cannot build top tier teams drafting like this.
Man this crap goes back to Artie Burns,Jarvis Jones, Devin Bush, Najee Harris, Kenny Pickett, Broderick Jones.
That’s six different drafts with busts at the first round pick. Not good!



Ley’s hope this new regime can reverse that trend.




Salute the nation
 
I see both sides to this but I think it’s going to be whatever they can get for him.
Man have we taken a nose dive drafting number one players over the past dozen years. Far too many busts with number ones not receiving second contracts or even getting their fifth year options picked up. You simply cannot build top tier teams drafting like this.
Man this crap goes back to Artie Burns,Jarvis Jones, Devin Bush, Najee Harris, Kenny Pickett, Broderick Jones.
That’s six different drafts with busts at the first round pick. Not good!

Calling Najee a bust is inaccurate

We definitely had more important needs and should have never drafted him, but 1000 yards per season on the tragically stifled Tomlin offense is hardly a bust.

BJ got a freak injury as did Bush…but they have been pretty awful in general as far as the bottom line payoff from their first round picks.

It almost makes the trading away of a first for Minkah make sense as bad as they have been in the 1st.
 
Calling Najee a bust is inaccurate

We definitely had more important needs and should have never drafted him, but 1000 yards per season on the tragically stifled Tomlin offense is hardly a bust.

BJ got a freak injury as did Bush…but they have been pretty awful in general as far as the bottom line payoff from their first round picks.

It almost makes the trading away of a first for Minkah make sense as bad as they have been in the 1st.
I get what you’re saying with Najee. I hated the pick and thought he was drafted way too early for them.
1000 yards to me isn’t what it once was. Getting that in 14 games like they played back in the day with Franco and Rocky, that’s an accomplishment.
In 17 games it just doesn’t have the same sparkle for me.
They had other needs that draft for sure but this stunk of you know who meddling in the draft.
 
Calling Najee a bust is inaccurate

We definitely had more important needs and should have never drafted him, but 1000 yards per season on the tragically stifled Tomlin offense is hardly a bust.

BJ got a freak injury as did Bush…but they have been pretty awful in general as far as the bottom line payoff from their first round picks.

It almost makes the trading away of a first for Minkah make sense as bad as they have been in the 1st.
agreed. how many backs have gotten 1000 the 1st 4 years? 10-15? not many
 
I get what you’re saying with Najee. I hated the pick and thought he was drafted way too early for them.
1000 yards to me isn’t what it once was. Getting that in 14 games like they played back in the day with Franco and Rocky, that’s an accomplishment.
In 17 games it just doesn’t have the same sparkle for me.
They had other needs that draft for sure but this stunk of you know who meddling in the draft.



Bettis’ 1000 yard seasons count as well.

That Era 1000 yard rushers ended or changed around the 2010-is as the league leaned towards more scoring, making air-yards more convenient. That slowed the rushing, but actually made it easier to rush as well. Lighter defenses to cover the receiving advantage.

I think modern day rules and comparison of the “old” 1000 yard rushers as to today would take a 1,200 yard rusher.





Salute the nation
 
agreed. how many backs have gotten 1000 the 1st 4 years? 10-15? not many


Najee was very good, he carried this awful offense his first two season.

He gains his first 4 seasons with a 1000+ yards which is no small feat when that “jack-****” offense was involved.

Anyone remember the O’Canada crapola ???

Najee3 just didn’t have the break-away speed needed in this Era.




Salute the nation
 
Jones will have a limited market because I'm not sure many teams will look at him as a swing tackle. I think there's some out there who think he's LT only.


Jones is a very big “risk” with his injury and weight deficiency needed.

Someone will take the chance, but at what price because they all know he is limited until he proves he isn’t.

You’d be extremely fortunate to get a 4th currently, more like a 6th / 7th until if determined we cut or not.

EDIT: Take note that if he even looks to regain mobility and strength, you keep him.




Salute the nation
 
Last edited:
There was a GM that gave up too much for Claypool. Plenty of other GMs that gave up too much stock. Again it is a premium position with a higher demand than availability.

Yes but no, a lot of Claypool’s issues stem from Claypool, the quarterback room, the OC, and the coaching at the time. That was not an egregious reach. He had around 850 yards and nine receiving TDs plus two rushing tds as a rookie. He had 850 receiving yards as a second year pro. NFL position coaches should be able to improve a player when it comes to catching the ball with their hands and high-pointing the football. That’s before we get into route running. You should not be coaching at that level if you can’t develop or improve upon fundamentals. If you need another example, we have our man GP1. He just stayed the same here and then… top 5 in most major statistical categories. Oh yes, that’s all about Dak and CeeDee. It has nothing to do with anyone or anything else.

I see both sides to this but I think it’s going to be whatever they can get for him.
Man have we taken a nose dive drafting number one players over the past dozen years. Far too many busts with number ones not receiving second contracts or even getting their fifth year options picked up. You simply cannot build top tier teams drafting like this.
Man this crap goes back to Artie Burns,Jarvis Jones, Devin Bush, Najee Harris, Kenny Pickett, Broderick Jones.
That’s six different drafts with busts at the first round pick. Not good!

You lost me with that one. He was behind a porous offensive line, got the crap kicked out of him, lost a step and that further contributed to his vision deteriorating. You’d have needed prime Barry Sanders back there to make that work. What can be said? The holes did get smaller coming from Alabama, giggity, giggity alright! Oh well, I guess Josh Jacobs was an option before that. You know what they say, no risk it, no biscuit. You’re telling me Artie Burns wasn’t elite? Man, I thought having the name Art or Dan automatically made someone a top tier talent or elite performer worthy of all opportunities, praise and hype. Thank you for providing a counter example to an opinion that I wholeheartedly believed to be close to truth sent directly from God. Is Artie any good at construction? I have a company for him. Well, it was fun to churn the pot with ye fine folks, toodles.
 
Last edited:
Yes but no, a lot of Claypool’s issues stem from Claypool, the quarterback room, the OC, and the coaching at the time. That was not an egregious reach. He had around 850 yards and nine receiving TDs plus two rushing tds as a rookie. He had 850 receiving yards as a second year pro. NFL position coaches should be able to improve a player when it comes to catching the ball with their hands and high-pointing the football. That’s before we get into route running. You should not be coaching at that level if you can’t develop or improve upon fundamentals. If you need another example, we have our man GP1. He just stayed the same here and then… top 5 in most major statistical categories. Oh yes, that’s all about Dak and CeeDee. It has nothing to do with anyone or anything else.



You lost me with that one. He was behind a porous offensive line, got the crap kicked out of him, lost a step and that further contributed to his vision deteriorating. You’d have needed prime Barry Sanders back there to make that work. What can be said? The holes did get smaller coming from Alabama, giggity, giggity alright! Oh well, I guess Josh Jacobs was an option before that. You know what they say, no risk it, no biscuit. You’re telling me Artie Burns wasn’t elite? Man, I thought having the name Art or Dan automatically made someone a top tier talent or elite performer worthy of all opportunities, praise and hype. Thank you for providing a counter example to an opinion that I wholeheartedly believed to be close to truth sent directly from God. Is Artie any good at construction? I have a company for him. Well, it was fun to churn the pot with ye fine folks, toodles.
Huh! Holy crap! Slash, help!
 
Top