• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Top 5 Time!

Top Five Steelers:

Stallworth (If Stallworth and Swan played in today's NFL their numbers would be much higher)
Swann
Ward (The most complete receiver of the group because of his devastating blocking)
Lipps (He had no QB when he played here).
Brown (If he keeps the current pace up he will move to top of list.I have no reason to believe that he won't).

Top 5 current NFL

Calvin Johnson
Antonio Brown
Dez Bryant
A J Green
Julio Jones and O'dell Beckham Jr. A tie.
 
steelhurt said:
Top Five Steelers:

Stallworth (If Stallworth and Swan played in today's NFL their numbers would be much higher)
Swann
Ward (The most complete receiver of the group because of his devastating blocking)
Lipps (He had no QB when he played here).
Brown (If he keeps the current pace up he will move to top of list.I have no reason to believe that he won't).

Top 5 current NFL

Calvin Johnson
Antonio Brown
Dez Bryant
A J Green
Julio Jones and O'dell Beckham Jr. A tie.
Click to expand...


Comment on your top 5 current.......... There was a time when fitzgerald would have been on this list, but NOT today. Not sure about O'dell as his famous catch has propelled popularity, his play is good but, I think his popularity has excceeded his ability.




Salute the nation
 
You might want to check out O'dells stats during the last half of the season, incredible.
 
In his last nine games Odell had 81 catches for 1189 yards and 9 TDs. He had 7 10 yard games and in the other 2 he had 93 and 90 yards. Those are.not great stats they are all time great stats.
 
Steelbar said:
In his last nine games Odell had 81 catches for 1189 yards and 9 TDs. He had 7 10 yard games and in the other 2 he had 93 and 90 yards. Those are.not great stats they are all time great stats.
Click to expand...

Those are great stats.......................... why didn't he play the full season??? NOT dissing O'dell, just a lot of hype went into that catch. He is a very good player, with a lot of hype.



Salute the nation
 
He was injured early and was a rookie. He is arguably the best WR in the league. I don't understand your logic.
 
Consistency at the position is important as well. He had 7 ten yard games so for seven games he was a non factor. Now that could be for any number of reasons including being injured but 9 games does not a season make. AB on the other hand produces over and over and is on a team that has many other talents at the receiving position so the opportunities are reduced from what he might have. Your choice might become what you think he will but as you alluded to be prepared for an argument.
 
He had 7 100 yard games 2 games with 93 and 90 yards and the first 3 games of his career with 44,28 and 34 yards, that is incredibly consistent and better than ABs season.
 
Last edited:
Steelbar said:
He was injured early and was a rookie. He is arguably the best WR in the league. I don't understand your logic.
Click to expand...



That is OK young padawon, my logic is not understandable at times. I THINK O'dell GOT A LOT OFG HYPE FROM THAT ONE CATCH. HE IS A VERY GOOD PLAYER, WITH A LOT OF HYPE.



Salute the nation
 
His hype had.nothing to do with the consistency and staggering numbers he put up his last 9 games, numbers that no one in history has touched but Jerry Rice .
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top