• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Steelers place the right of first refusal tender on AA Ron.

topseed said:
Totally agree. In fact, I'm thinking @Gildong Sack should change his username to @HangingfromRodgers'Sac.

It's not just you. You damn sure won't have to convince @Coryea to join you in choosing Ben over Rodgers. :love::love:
Click to expand...
Rodgers was a great QB. No argument there. Arguing for the Rodgers we have now and as the GOAT is laughable.
 
Shane Falco said:
Bringing AR12 back would help everyone understand McCarthys concept. Yeah, he’s not the coordinator but we all know McCarthy will have major input. Now they can develop without Rodgers, but if you can bring in a guy that can help the WRs, TEs and the QBs understand it. Do it. To me, this is a transitional year anyways.
Click to expand...
I can't stand the guy but one thing AR was still a master at was catching the other teams offsides, having too many men on the field, etc. If he can help pass that down to the young QBs, it would be a plus.
 
JMM said:
I can't stand the guy but one thing AR was still a master at was catching the other teams offsides, having too many men on the field, etc. If he can help pass that down to the young QBs, it would be a plus.
Click to expand...


You're right, but add that there are a lot of things the Aaa-Ron can teach the young-iNs.

He will teach, but not in a backup role.

I don’t think he would take being benched lightly, even for obvious bad play.

I still think he plays here as the Steelers will sign him.

I don’t want him and want to see the current room take over.




Salute the nation
 
Drink IRON City said:
You're right, but add that there are a lot of things the Aaa-Ron can teach the young-iNs.

He will teach, but not in a backup role.

I don’t think he would take being benched lightly, even for obvious bad play.

I still think he plays here as the Steelers will sign him.

I don’t want him and want to see the current room take over.




Salute the nation
Click to expand...
Agreed. No idea if he provided insight to Mason or Howard last year or not.
 
JMM said:
Agreed. No idea if he provided insight to Mason or Howard last year or not.
Click to expand...


I thought I’d read that Howard was very complimentary towards Aaa-Ron’s mentorship / season.



Salute the nation
 
stillwright said:
And in the end he won "one" SB and that almost didn't happen. Seriously.. isn't that the end goal...to win SBs? He did it....Just once though. While being on teams(stacked) and meant to win SB's.. he kind of under preformed historically in the that area one could easily say. No?

Really though. Your definition of someone being the GOAT is drastically different than mine. To each there own. Just hard to swallow reading your posts referring him as the GOAT here on a Steeler message board. Leaves a bad taste in ones mouth. Dude played one average to below average season as a qb here in Pittsburgh. Just laughable to me. That's my opinion though. I guess I will do me and you do you.
Click to expand...
I hear you. I'll try to avoid that from now on and just call him Rodgers.

I look at the athlete..to me Bo Jackson is the greatest running back I've ever seen run the football. To me he is the G..t running back. Don't care about his short career or Super Bowls. The only possible competitor to that crown for me is Sanders. Now, I didn't get to watch Jim Brown live or any of the older guys, but I grew up watching Payton, OJ, Franco,Dorsett, Csonka, Barry Sanders, etc.

Emmitt Smith has how many rings? I wouldn't call anyone the best because of SB rings, I don't even consider Smith top 10. Everyone knows about that Dallas O line.

Aaron Rodgers is probably the greatest pure passer the NFL has ever seen. Hard to think of someone better.
 
slashsteel said:
Perhaps. I do know Pittman is outside and slot capable . So even if Pittman is outside I am sure he will get some inside looks as well. As magic Mike has been preaching versatility…
Click to expand...

Just think of the possibilities if this leadership group moved players around and the other team didn’t know where players would even be lining up along with not knowing the play that would be called…just imagine what could happen?!?!?!?

This could be simply magical to watch…
Finally a game of chess being played when we’ve been watching checkers for years…it may not even have been checkers, it may have been tic-tac-toe.
 
JMM said:
I can't stand the guy but one thing AR was still a master at was catching the other teams offsides, having too many men on the field, etc. If he can help pass that down to the young QBs, it would be a plus.
Click to expand...

Thing is, actual game reps would teach Allar or Howard so much more than learning the art of catching a team offsides 3-4 times a year from the dinosaur.

Just watch film, have some field awareness and most importantly a center that is ready for the quick snap can get that done…they can watch the dinosaur’s past plays that were successful and learn as much as they are going to in that aspect.

Rodgers is just another year of delays to the the inevitable and as GHD as bringing back Tomlin would have been.
 
Fiji Mariner said:
Just think of the possibilities if this leadership group moved players around and the other team didn’t know where players would even be lining up along with not knowing the play that would be called…just imagine what could happen?!?!?!?

This could be simply magical to watch…
Finally a game of chess being played when we’ve been watching checkers for years…it may not even have been checkers, it may have been tic-tac-toe.
Click to expand...
Other teams preferred to call it tic tac - we know

An interesting game in which the opponent knows what you are doing and what you want to do but you do it anyways.
 
Gildong Sack said:
How dare you.... And get your hands of my Rodgers'Sac!
Topseed is the bloke who got me on the Rodgers'Sac Peepuul!
Click to expand...

That was a complete waste of 69 seconds of my life, but at least you're being a good sport about it (I think). (y)
 
SteelerInLebanon said:
His arm was shot. He even seems to admit that now.
Click to expand...
Ben after elbow surgery 55 TD's 7,500 yards in two seasons. The year after elbow surgery, he had 3 WR's put up better numbers than DK Metcalf did, and none of them were paid as the #4 WR in the NFL. JuJu 97 catches, Dionte 88 catches, Chase(rookie)67 catches, a rookie who hasn't done a damn thing in the NFL since, had a better year than DK Metcalf did with Rodgers. The following season Dionte was a 107 catch almost 1200 yard WR, Dionte F'n Johnson. This was the Oline Dan Moore (rookie), Dotson(2nd year) Kendrick Green(rookie), Trai Turner, Okafor. I don't think I need to mention who is OC's were.

I think you guys are all missing point, as usual when anyone brings up Ben, no one is saying we should've kept him around longer than we did, we're saying they forced him to retire, a franchise all-time great, same as Troy, Hines, etc. but here we are allowing a 42 year old guy that hasn't done a damn thing here, and was sh!t vs playoff teams last year, string us along all while giving him better weapons and giving him a better Oline.
 
Coryea said:
Ben after elbow surgery 55 TD's 7,500 yards in two seasons. The year after elbow surgery, he had 3 WR's put up better numbers than DK Metcalf did, and none of them were paid as the #4 WR in the NFL. JuJu 97 catches, Dionte 88 catches, Chase(rookie)67 catches, a rookie who hasn't done a damn thing in the NFL since, had a better year than DK Metcalf did with Rodgers. The following season Dionte was a 107 catch almost 1200 yard WR, Dionte F'n Johnson. This was the Oline Dan Moore (rookie), Dotson(2nd year) Kendrick Green(rookie), Trai Turner, Okafor. I don't think I need to mention who is OC's were.

I think you guys are all missing point, as usual when anyone brings up Ben, no one is saying we should've kept him around longer than we did, we're saying they forced him to retire, a franchise all-time great, same as Troy, Hines, etc. but here we are allowing a 42 year old guy that hasn't done a damn thing here, and was sh!t vs playoff teams last year, string us along all while giving him better weapons and giving him a better Oline.
Click to expand...
He had some good numbers, but he was also not the same guy he was before. I hated to see him go but it was time and he seems to realize that now.

The difference between him and Rodgers, and this isn't a criticism of Ben, is that Rodgers of the two has more to offer in a mentorship role to a young QB than Ben would have. Aaron might not be the physical player he was, but he played smart football and has things to teach a young QB. Ben was just a great natural and instinctual QB which doesn't translate well to teaching. Neither of the young guys are ready to play and sitting one more year with Aaron would be good for both IMHO.
 
SteelerInLebanon said:
He had some good numbers, but he was also not the same guy he was before. I hated to see him go but it was time and he seems to realize that now.

The difference between him and Rodgers, and this isn't a criticism of Ben, is that Rodgers of the two has more to offer in a mentorship role to a young QB than Ben would have. Aaron might not be the physical player he was, but he played smart football and has things to teach a young QB. Ben was just a great natural and instinctual QB which doesn't translate well to teaching. Neither of the young guys are ready to play and sitting one more year with Aaron would be good for both IMHO.
Click to expand...
Again, no one is suggesting Ben should've stayed longer than he did, where is that coming from? I have't seen anyone saying that? It's the fact that they told Ben it was time to go basically, but they can't do that to a broken down Rodgers? Anyone that watched him knows it's time for him to go. Rodgers isn't the same guy as he was before the achilles either.

Well if Aaron had any thoughts of mentoring, his a55 would be here, I'm sick of hearing people bring that up, what makes anyone thinks he wants to spend his last season mentoring young guys? Smart football? Did you see the 2 pick sixes in the playoffs? He had a 65 rating vs playoff teams. US and him got embarrassed in the playoffs, every other QB showed up this spring, Mahomes, Allen, Darnold, 39 year old Stafford trying to get better for next year.
 
Some writer from CBS Sports has indicated that Arizona could be a possible landing spot for Rodgers. Their new offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett was the OC with the Packers in 2020 and 2021 during Rodgers' MVP seasons, and was also his OC with the Jets.

Please, let there be some meat on this bone.
 
I love everyone bringing up Rodgers as a mentor as a reason to bring him back. If Rodgers was going to be mentor/leader then he'd be here day 1. It's comical how some fans actually want this egomaniac tool bag back. If he cared about anyone but himself, specifically the team, he'd already be here. If the guy had any competitiveness left in him he'd be here after that embarrassment in the playoffs, but he's not, that tells me all I need to know. Stay in your darkness retreat. He can't even give them a yes or no answer GTFOH.
 
Last edited:
Coryea said:
Again, no one is suggesting Ben should've stayed longer than he did, where is that coming from? I have't seen anyone saying that? It's the fact that they told Ben it was time to go basically, but they can't do that to a broken down Rodgers? Anyone that watched him knows it's time for him to go. Rodgers isn't the same guy as he was before the achilles either.

Well if Aaron had any thoughts of mentoring, his a55 would be here, I'm sick of hearing people bring that up, what makes anyone thinks he wants to spend his last season mentoring young guys? Smart football? Did you see the 2 pick sixes in the playoffs? He had a 65 rating vs playoff teams. US and him got embarrassed in the playoffs, every other QB showed up this spring, Mahomes, Allen, Darnold, 39 year old Stafford trying to get better for next year.
Click to expand...
I thought Rodgers could be a good mentor to the young guys as well. But you are absolutely right. He ain't mentoring anyone not being there. I just don't get his stance. It isn't like he is thinking about ditch digging or something.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top