• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Pickens would not have had this success here

Paying this guy 34 million a year is beyond stupid.
I'm sure every team in the league is dying to pay 34 million to a guy who's been middle of the road his entire career. Averaging 55 yards a game.
yeah, sure
There is no team in the league taking DK at 34 million over Pickens, even if the pricetag was the same let alone 33 million less
I'd like to know how/why you keep regurgitating this $34 million number, when DK's cap hit is around 11 million this season and 31 million in 2026. Plus the Steelers can buy him out for 18 million in dead cap prior to 2027 if they want to.

Yes, they're overpaying the guy, but at least get the figures right.
 
Nobody in Dallas gives a shlt if Pickens is "acting up." Just like Tomlin and the Steelers didn't give a shlt when AB was "acting up" while he led the NFL in receiving yards in two different seasons.

The Cowboys are not losing because of GP and his 91 yards receiving a game...why is this so hard for you to comprehend? They have much bigger problems than an occasional personal foul penalty on George Pickens.
Agree....at the end of the day he should still be here.
 
Nobody in Dallas gives a shlt if Pickens is "acting up." Just like Tomlin and the Steelers didn't give a shlt when AB was "acting up" while he led the NFL in receiving yards in two different seasons.

The Cowboys are not losing because of GP and his 91 yards receiving a game...why is this so hard for you to comprehend? They have much bigger problems than an occasional personal foul penalty on George Pickens.
Maybe someone is, if the token discipline of Monday night means anything.

Glad you brought up AB. The Cowboys aren't winning. The Steelers didn't win anything during the whole AB era. It was fun football to watch, for sure. Was all the drama worth it though?
 
Another major issue with Pickens is contract. After this year someone is going to have to make a 30 mil / yr commitment to him. I can not blame the steelers for not taking that risk. Personally I would have kept him this year and if it didn't work out just cut our losses. I understand they were trying to get something for him.
 
Another major issue with Pickens is contract. After this year someone is going to have to make a 30 mil / yr commitment to him. I can not blame the steelers for not taking that risk. Personally I would have kept him this year and if it didn't work out just cut our losses. I understand they were trying to get something for him.
And here it is. Why commit to a player you feel isn’t a team player, disrupts team chemistry? Do you throw a boat load of money at him and risk an AB recurrence? With the track record of players under Mike Tomlin that were shipped out? The answer should be a resounding no.

It isn’t what I or Joe blow desire it is what is best for the team.

And that is the bottom line cause stone cold slash says so.

😅
 
I remember reading somewhere that the reason women have more than 1 kid is because they forget pain. If it was up to men, the population would be very low. Steeler fans are like women in that regard. We went through AB, JuJu, Claypool, Diontae and all that went with them, but now we are mad they got rid of Pickens. I guess some forget the pain.

I am not blaming Pickens for the Cowboys losing. But they are even with all the shiny stats. Is it worth dealing with what he brings, even though he is a great talent?
 
Tomlin and his short pass game isn't attractive to wr's that want the ball, the camera. The glory.
Unless you offer them $30 mill plus a season....that is.
 
I remember reading somewhere that the reason women have more than 1 kid is because they forget pain. If it was up to men, the population would be very low. Steeler fans are like women in that regard. We went through AB, JuJu, Claypool, Diontae and all that went with them, but now we are mad they got rid of Pickens. I guess some forget the pain.

I am not blaming Pickens for the Cowboys losing. But they are even with all the shiny stats. Is it worth dealing with what he brings, even though he is a great talent?
None of those other guys went on to do sh!t anywhere else, that's why the uproar, but Pickens wouldn't be doing what he's doing if he were still here.
 
What has been their opponent defensive strength on a case by case basis? How good is their O-line at pass pro?

Funny how you don't mention Addison...he has 412 yards receiving to Jefferson's 747. That makes life a lot easier for Jefferson...hell if Addison is their #2 then Nailor is 2B or maybe 3...and he has 318 yards receiving so far. I researched that because I don't know their team, but I do know things like this aren't as simple as you think.

DK has 551 yards with NO #2.... What do we have for a #2? Well first of all we don't have a legit 2 , but let's say Austin is it. How many yards does he have? He has 242 yards so far.....LOL. And he is our top receiver not named Metcalf in yards.

How is that helping DK? It's not. That's why teams are able at times to take him(DK) out of games and that leaves Rodgers running for his life looking for one of the scrubs to come open.
Let me simplify this for you.
DK had this years leading receiver (Jackson smith Njigba) in the league as his #2 last year.
Guess what?
Turns out even with Smith Njigba opposite him, (also out producing him)
DK was still held to under 1000 yards.
So there goes the not having a #2 excuse

Even with this years top producing WR opposite him his production was
Almost identical to this years production
Also almost identical to his career avg over 6 seasons
 
The argument has been that Pickens wouldn't have acted up as much if Tomlin had a better offense leading to Pickens having more targets and stats. He has that in Dallas, and he is still acting up. And they have a losing record. Is dealing with him worth it? It isn't leading to greater team success, especially in light of the fact that his actions on occasion may have hurt the Cowboy's chances in a few games. That was my point.
You are arguing the 2nd most receiving yards in the league have hurt the cowboys chances in multiple games?
Please explain how you came to this brilliant conclusion
 
I'd like to know how/why you keep regurgitating this $34 million number, when DK's cap hit is around 11 million this season and 31 million in 2026. Plus the Steelers can buy him out for 18 million in dead cap prior to 2027 if they want to.

Yes, they're overpaying the guy, but at least get the figures right.
His average annual value is 32.99 million, I was wrong.
If the Steelers bought him out after 2 seasons
60 million is fully guaranteed.
 
You are arguing the 2nd most receiving yards in the league have hurt the cowboys chances in multiple games?
Please explain how you came to this brilliant conclusion
They were driving late against the Eagles in the first game of the year down 24-20. They were deep in Eagles territory and he took a dumb personal foul penalty and blew up that drive. As the Cowboys were getting something going against the Cardinals and he took another personal foul for taunting as they were getting going. He directly hurt his team in two games. It isn't all about putting up stats. That is one of the problems with too many of these wide receiver divas. And it has spread to fans as well the way it looks by your response. If they are putting up stats, it doesn't matter what else they do.

Terrell Owens never was on a championship team with all of his stats. Guys like this are draining to a team, even with all their talent and stats.
 
They were driving late against the Eagles in the first game of the year down 24-20. They were deep in Eagles territory and he took a dumb personal foul penalty and blew up that drive. As the Cowboys were getting something going against the Cardinals and he took another personal foul for taunting as they were getting going. He directly hurt his team in two games. It isn't all about putting up stats. That is one of the problems with too many of these wide receiver divas. And it has spread to fans as well the way it looks by your response. If they are putting up stats, it doesn't matter what else they do.

Terrell Owens never was on a championship team with all of his stats. Guys like this are draining to a team, even with all their talent and stats.
Would you rather have Pickens or Austin as our #2?
 
Would you rather have Pickens or Austin as our #2?
technically our #2 option in the Arthur Smith offense is supposed to be a TE. We traded for a TE that caught 88 passes last year in Miami, so our #1 WR we traded for and our TE we traded for are having bad years, shocker, it can't be the system can it?
 
technically our #2 option in the Arthur Smith offense is supposed to be a TE. We traded for a TE that caught 88 passes last year in Miami, so our #1 WR we traded for and our TE we traded for are having bad years, shocker, it can't be the system can it?
What i want is a team that has more likeable guys on it, whatever positions that is. No, I don't want Pickens on the team. I could care less about his numbers. I'd remember the 70s teams, the 90s teams and the 2000s teams. They had likeable players all over the roster you could root for. When was the last time anyone felt that about a Steeler team?

And you can win with those kind of guys. The Steelers proved it in 05 and 08.
 
Neither? There were other options.
The question though was...who would you rather have between them? Pickens? Austin?
 
The question though was...who would you rather have between them? Pickens? Austin?
I'll take Austin. See above. It's not that I dislike Pickens. I am indifferent toward most of the guys on the team, but it would be nice to have guys you really like and root for.
 
Let me simplify this for you.
DK had this years leading receiver (Jackson smith Njigba) in the league as his #2 last year.
Guess what?
Turns out even with Smith Njigba opposite him, (also out producing him)
DK was still held to under 1000 yards.
So there goes the not having a #2 excuse

Even with this years top producing WR opposite him his production was
Almost identical to this years production
Also almost identical to his career avg over 6 seasons
Don't gloss over the fact that DK played in 2 less games and was short of 1000 by only 8yrds. Also Smith was QB last year vs Darnold this year
 
Maybe someone is, if the token discipline of Monday night means anything.
Yes, I'm sure that sitting him out for one series sure taught George a grand lesson.
Glad you brought up AB. The Cowboys aren't winning. The Steelers didn't win anything during the whole AB era. It was fun football to watch, for sure. Was all the drama worth it though?
Yes, it was AB's fault that the Steelers lost 45-42 to Jacksonville in the first round of the 2018 playoffs. Those 7 catches for 132 yards and 2 touchdowns just weren't enough. Great point.
 
Yes, I'm sure that sitting him out for one series sure taught George a grand lesson.

Yes, it was AB's fault that the Steelers lost 45-42 to Jacksonville in the first round of the 2018 playoffs. Those 7 catches for 132 yards and 2 touchdowns just weren't
Hence the word token. But you said nobody gives a shiit. Maybe a little shiit, anyway.

You continue with this narrative which is fine. I'm not blaming AB or Pickens. I'm stating the facts that the Steelers didn’t win and neither are the Cowboys. Since that is the case, is all that comes with players like this worth it? I don't think so. You seem to think it's fine.
 
Last edited:
His average annual value is 32.99 million, I was wrong.
If the Steelers bought him out after 2 seasons
60 million is fully guaranteed.
The Steelers are not going to take a $41.5 million cap hit in 2029 when DK is 32 years old. It'll never average out to that, because they'll cut or trade him before then. Even they aren't that stupid.
 
What i want is a team that has more likeable guys on it, whatever positions that is. No, I don't want Pickens on the team. I could care less about his numbers. I'd remember the 70s teams, the 90s teams and the 2000s teams. They had likeable players all over the roster you could root for. When was the last time anyone felt that about a Steeler team?

And you can win with those kind of guys. The Steelers proved it in 05 and 08.

If we had social media and 24x7x365 NFL coverage in the 70s I wonder if we’d remember those guys as likeable.
 
Top