• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Steelers running the football is the dumbest thing they can do...

Stryker

Podcast/ VidCast/ Writer
Contributor
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
16,586
Reaction score
20,450
Points
113
Location
Section 228
A lot of people here are losing their minds, and some are even losing their ability to understand the rules of football in general. In a game the Steelers won by 15 points, there seems to be a point of contention on whether the Steelers should have run the ball with 11sec on the game clock holding a TO. I've argued ad nauseum in 2 other threads why it shouldn't have hurt this team's ability to run 2 more plays after a run, but I will state another game situation where the exact play was called, with zero timeouts and a game on the line.

October 1st 2015. A game against the Chargers in San Diego, came down to a single play, on the one yard line, down by 3 with Vick at QB. San Diego was outplaying the Steelers all day with Vick at QB. A pick 6 by Blake helped make that game close as well as a late 72yd catch and run by Wheaton put the Steelers in position to win late. They could have kicked a FG and force OT, but the way they were playing on offense, the percentages were higher to gain 1 yard to win (70-80%), then to go overtime on the road when you aren't performing well on offense (40-50%).

The Steelers rolled the dice and ran left with Bell, who was hit in the backfield, spun off of it, and extended for the TD and the walkoff win.

This was a gutsy decision, made on the last play of the game, giving the Steelers the best percentage chance to win it. Had the Steelers failed to make that 1 yard, Tomlin, and Haley would have both been ostracized for their decisions. On this day, it was the right one, both by the percentages, and in the win column.
 
It's the TIME OUT call that i'm wondering about. Why did it take so long?? NO need to explain that as I know the factors and think both CMVT and BR need spanked for that gaff. I'd say a "time out" in the corner but they have NO time outs left.




Salute the nation
 
And that play was made right in front of me, in that end zone. Great ending to a very ****** played game with Vick at QB
 
And that play was made right in front of me, in that end zone. Great ending to a very ****** played game with Vick at QB

Super awesome you were there for that play!. To date, it is my all time favorite Bell play. Until his Superbowl touchdowns!
 
October 1st 2015. A game against the Chargers in San Diego, came down to a single play, on the one yard line, down by 3 with Vick at QB. San Diego was outplaying the Steelers all day with Vick at QB. A pick 6 by Blake helped make that game close as well as a late 72yd catch and run by Wheaton put the Steelers in position to win late. They could have kicked a FG and force OT, but the way they were playing on offense, the percentages were higher to gain 1 yard to win (70-80%), then to go overtime on the road when you aren't performing well on offense (40-50%).

The Steelers rolled the dice and ran left with Bell, who was hit in the backfield, spun off of it, and extended for the TD and the walkoff win.

This was a gutsy decision, made on the last play of the game......


I was at that game, FREAKING INCREDIBLE.....Turned around and all the CHARGER FANS WERE GONE
 
A lot of people here are losing their minds, and some are even losing their ability to understand the rules of football in general. In a game the Steelers won by 15 points, there seems to be a point of contention on whether the Steelers should have run the ball with 11sec on the game clock holding a TO. I've argued ad nauseum in 2 other threads why it shouldn't have hurt this team's ability to run 2 more plays after a run, but I will state another game situation where the exact play was called, with zero timeouts and a game on the line.

October 1st 2015. A game against the Chargers in San Diego, came down to a single play, on the one yard line, down by 3 with Vick at QB. San Diego was outplaying the Steelers all day with Vick at QB. A pick 6 by Blake helped make that game close as well as a late 72yd catch and run by Wheaton put the Steelers in position to win late. They could have kicked a FG and force OT, but the way they were playing on offense, the percentages were higher to gain 1 yard to win (70-80%), then to go overtime on the road when you aren't performing well on offense (40-50%).

The Steelers rolled the dice and ran left with Bell, who was hit in the backfield, spun off of it, and extended for the TD and the walkoff win.

This was a gutsy decision, made on the last play of the game, giving the Steelers the best percentage chance to win it. Had the Steelers failed to make that 1 yard, Tomlin, and Haley would have both been ostracized for their decisions. On this day, it was the right one, both by the percentages, and in the win column.

Just so I am clear on your argument, the pecentages are the same from the 5 yard line and the 1 yard line?
Are these the "rules of football" you are speaking of?
 
Just so I am clear on your argument, the pecentages are the same from the 5 yard line and the 1 yard line?
Are these the "rules of football" you are speaking of?

From the 5 the percentages are not nearly as high as a 1 yard stretch run. The point is in a situation, where the game is on the line, we've been successful at running a successful stretch play with Bell.
 
You don't run up the gut on a short yardage with no blockers in the backfield!

load up big and run 3rd and one - so simple even an idiot coach should understand


Are you saying are coach isn't an idiot????




Salute the nation
 
I agree 100%, in fact I even called for a Bell run in the game thread right before that happened. I’m happy with the play call, just wish it would have worked. And wish we could have got the TO in time to run one more. That was ridiculous that every player on that field wasn’t immediately signaling


Sent from my iPhone using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
We were at the 1 yard line in 2015, we were at the 6 or 7 yesterday, theres a solid chance of getting a yard, the% of running in from the 6 or 7 is pretty low, and if Bell gets outside and his tackled at the one you only have time to kick a FG. Throw it and take two shots into the end zone

Sent from my XT1585 using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
We were on the 5
 
I was with you on Ben being to blame also on the timeout. But this is a....stretch...
 
From the 5 the percentages are not nearly as high as a 1 yard stretch run. The point is in a situation, where the game is on the line, we've been successful at running a successful stretch play with Bell.

What does a high percentage 1 yard run from 2 years ago have to do with a low percentage 5 yard run yesterday?
What a dumb call. Choose a low percentage run giving them 1 chance at a touchdown when they obvoiusly had time for two passes to the endzone?
 
The play yesterday was a slow developing play with 7 men in the box. Not a good call no matter which way you look at it. If you pass you are guaranteed at least 2 plays or a TD unless there is a turnover. Sure the TO should have given us an extra play, but we should not have been in that situation to start with. Even if we get the TO with 7 seconds left it is possible the clock would have ran out on the next play and get 0 points.
 
What does a high percentage 1 yard run from 2 years ago have to do with a low percentage 5 yard run yesterday?
What a dumb call. Choose a low percentage run giving them 1 chance at a touchdown when they obvoiusly had time for two passes to the endzone?

It mattered because of reasons. Oh and because Bell is supposed to get the ball in goal line situations.
 
The time on clock not calling time out and running wide is question I have with the play.
 
It mattered because of reasons. Oh and because Bell is supposed to get the ball in goal line situations.

You wanna talk all this and that about percentages and goal line. This wasn't even a goal line situation? 5 yard line. Your logic is so stupid even you can't explain it. "It mattered because of reasons"
 
You wanna talk all this and that about percentages and goal line. This wasn't even a goal line situation? 5 yard line. Your logic is so stupid even you can't explain it. "It mattered because of reasons"

It is definitely a goal to go situation. They are comparable to those who are not obtuse.
 
Top