• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Brain Injury Found in 43 Percent of Living NFL Veterans

Elfiero

Banned
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
3,622
Reaction score
494
Points
83
http://www.newsmax.com/t/newsmax/article/723428
Some 43 percent of retired American football players studied show signs of traumatic brain injury, raising new concerns about the long-term effects of hitting and tackling, researchers said Monday.

The study involved 40 retired National Football League (NFL) players, who underwent thinking and memory tests as well as brain scans.

"This is one of the largest studies to date in living retired NFL players and one of the first to demonstrate significant objective evidence for traumatic brain injury in these former players," said study author Francis Conidi of the Florida State University College of Medicine.


"The rate of traumatic brain injury was significantly higher in the players than that found in the general population."

The players ranged in age from 27 to 56 and played an average of seven years in the league.

Most had been out of the NFL for fewer than five years.

They reported an average of eight concussions.

Around a third of the players said they had sustained several hits that were not strong enough to be diagnosed as concussions.

The findings, based on sensitive MRI scans called diffusion tensor imaging, were released ahead of a presentation at the American Academy of Neurology's 68th Annual Meeting in Vancouver, Canada.


The advanced MRI scans measured the movement of water molecules in the brain's white matter -- which controls how the brain functions -- to determine the amount of damage.

"Seventeen players, or 43 percent, had levels of movement 2.5 standard deviations below those of healthy people of the same age, which is considered evidence of traumatic brain injury with a less than one percent error rate," the study said.

"On the tests of thinking skills, about 50 percent had significant problems on executive function, 45 percent on learning or memory, 42 percent on attention and concentration."

Longer careers tended to put players at higher risk of TBI, but researchers established no link between higher concussion numbers and brain injury.

The findings could help scientists better understand the brain condition known as chronic traumatic encephalopathy, which is associated with aggression, dementia, depression and suicide.


"This research in living players sheds light on the possible pathological changes consistent with chronic traumatic encephalopathy that may be taking place," Conidi said.

The latest evidence of widespread brain injury among football players, the findings may increase pressure on the NFL, which has long been under fire for downplaying the effects of concussions in the most popular US sport.
 
So many good responses of other groups with higher percentages of brain damage.........................so wrong forum to utilize any of them.
 
the numbers will be skewed when Wes Welker is tested.
 
The average NFL career lasts about 4 years.

The problem with this test is they are not doing a before ana after comparison! Test them as rookies, then test them as 7 year vets. Then it would matter. It should surprise few that many NFL players test poorly on the Wonderlic score.

"On the tests of thinking skills, about 50 percent had significant problems on executive function, 45 percent on learning or memory, 42 percent on attention and concentration."

Also, 8 concussions is a high amount. Most players have far less. I think the sample group of players tested does not reflect the average 7 year veteran.
 
it still is a delicate issue but the truth is that many people would jeopardize his future health to secure a living for his family. I know I would if I had the skills and athleticism dedicating 10 years of my life, in exchange for a few millions which would secure my grandkids living and education. If I get a good second contract I would call it a career after it ends and retire to the sunset in my boat with my longboard
 
Some of These players crave more than just the money. It's the fame / power / entitlement / that goes along with it. Many players stay way to long. Yes they want the money because they were foolish with the earlier money but the fame etc. is what keeps a lot of them there longer than they should be. Payton Manning, considered a BRAIN by many, has made BIG coin, yet stayed way past his ability. FAME etc..... BOTTOM line these guys know what can happen butr are chosing to stay. The older veterans may have a legitamite issue but the current boys don't.




Salute the nation
 
Some of These players crave more than just the money. It's the fame / power / entitlement / that goes along with it. Many players stay way to long. Yes they want the money because they were foolish with the earlier money but the fame etc. is what keeps a lot of them there longer than they should be. Payton Manning, considered a BRAIN by many, has made BIG coin, yet stayed way past his ability. FAME etc..... BOTTOM line these guys know what can happen butr are chosing to stay. The older veterans may have a legitamite issue but the current boys don't.




Salute the nation

This is perfect and I really think something that should be mentioned much more than it is. These players have been "the man" since their high school football days. Standing out above the rest, everybody seeking you out, talking about you, etc. Guys are afraid of getting out because they just become everyday people. Just like Ray Liotta says at the end of Goodfellas "I'm an average nobody, I get to live the rest of my life like a schnook." They try to stay in the limelight as much as possible either through broadcasting or coaching and a decent portion of them have no personality or as too dumb to do so(see Emmit Smith). When Mike Singletary was coaching the 49ers, some players would talk about how he would always refer to "his playing days." Guys got sick of it because it's not about "you" anymore. The media wants to cover that Junior Seau(RIP) had brain trauma as the reason for his suicide, but I don't think I've EVER heard anyone mention that being away from it all may have been a genuine problem for him.
 
Football is a contact sport. Its not a surprise these guys have health issues after retirement. They are consenting adults and know what they are getting into. Isnt it something like 75% of NFL retirees file for bankruptcy? Maybe just trying to get some $$$. I think the NFL may be on its last hurrah before these concussion issues start killing the game. Just the way society is turning at this point
 
And in other news cigarette smoking may cause lung cancer and many people are murdered in Chicago.
 
I do think the NFL should go with the better helmet designs that are out there. Those contracts with the current manufacturers need to be reworked to allow it.
 
I do think the NFL should go with the better helmet designs that are out there. Those contracts with the current manufacturers need to be reworked to allow it.

I'm sure that would help some, but how much?

The brain essentially floats inside the skull, so a hit even softened a bit doesn't stop the brain from bouncing.
 
I do think the NFL should go with the better helmet designs that are out there. Those contracts with the current manufacturers need to be reworked to allow it.

That's another issue that's worth a discussion. The "better" helmets have been available for a couple years but they look dorky so some of the image conscious players resist anything to do with them.

The new helmet flexes to help absorb head impact and incorporates what the company calls its "InSite Impact Response System -- the company's latest head impact monitoring technology."

22556547_BG1.jpg


speedflex_quarter_view_lr__2_.0.jpg


I guess we will have to wait to see if this new "light" thing will take hold.

Among the latest innovations: lights that flash after a concussion-causing hit, like the Reebok skull cap called check light, or a product from the Bethesda, Maryland-based company Brain Sentry, which has a sensor that clips on the back of the helmet.

For some reason the NFL is slow to mandate these kinds of change.
 
I do think the NFL should go with the better helmet designs that are out there. Those contracts with the current manufacturers need to be reworked to allow it.

Initially it was a money GREED thing to get as much as possible for the NFL. No I'm betting the NFL is rethinking the $$ vs impact (pun) of law suit and profit.

I'm sure that would help some, but how much?

The brain essentially floats inside the skull, so a hit even softened a bit doesn't stop the brain from bouncing.

You are right to a degre.......If some of the inertia and force can be softened, that much less impact or "bouncing" of the brain.


That's another issue that's worth a discussion. The "better" helmets have been available for a couple years but they look dorky so some of the image conscious players resist anything to do with them.

The new helmet flexes to help absorb head impact and incorporates what the company calls its "InSite Impact Response System -- the company's latest head impact monitoring technology."

22556547_BG1.jpg


speedflex_quarter_view_lr__2_.0.jpg


I guess we will have to wait to see if this new "light" thing will take hold.

Among the latest innovations: lights that flash after a concussion-causing hit, like the Reebok skull cap called check light, or a product from the Bethesda, Maryland-based company Brain Sentry, which has a sensor that clips on the back of the helmet.

For some reason the NFL is slow to mandate these kinds of change.


GREAT information here SteelChip, thank you. Yes, there is VERY much safer equipment out there and needs to be implemented. The big manufacturer and the prestige of supplying the NFL, needs to be rethought out.




Salute the nation
 
I Remeber about 25+ years or so ago, I read this book talking about how outdated football equipment was. I realize that things are better this day and age, but the thing that stuck out was a design proposed at that time. It was a somewhat normal looking pad system for the head and body. It had cables designed to tension and loose as per hit. This was for multiple body points and of coarse the head / helmet. At the time I read this I though what a concept. Now this day and age I'd think had that system Been incorporated and improved upon as tech. Allowed, WOW what a padding injury restricted version they'd have now. Kewl Beans



Salute the nation
 
The new helmet will not make any difference IMO. The average NFL player probably has 8-12 years of football BEFORE they get to the NFL. I'm fine making the same safer but all I'm guessing that most of the damage is already there before they get to the NFL and the increased speed/size just makes it worse.
 
Bud Grants perspective:

The MMQB: At this point, they can’t make any rule changes that increase the risk of head injury, from a political standpoint.


Grant: Look, I’ve had concussions. I played football and I watched football, all my four boys played football, I’ve got grandsons who play football. My son is a high school football coach. At some point we’re going to have to get to the point where before you play football I’m going to test you at some stage in your life to determine if you’re susceptible to concussions. We need a test that shows us that your brain is situated a certain way that puts you at risk. If you are susceptible, don’t play football. They don’t talk about that, but we’re going to have to come to that point.

I’m not a doctor. All I know is that some guys take a lot of hits and there’s no evidence there’s any residual effect to being concussed, myself being one. I remember being carried off a field. I don’t remember, but I know it happened. Was I concussed? Sure. But maybe I’m not susceptible to the residuals. You remember what I’m telling you, because some day these things will happen and I will be proven right.
 
They should do a comparable study on rugby players. Would help show some of the effect of equipment as well as tackling technique.
 
They should do studies against the regular population, against other sports, against soccer players, and they should have some measurable differentials they can explain. But they don't yet, so they have a bunch of scary "facts" with nothing to compare them against.

Come on Elfie, cut and paste something useful for a change!
 
Top