• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

15k fine for Hilton? Are you kidding?

Ike Kelly

Ike Kelly

P-38L Fan
Member
Contributor
Joined
Apr 18, 2014
Messages
4,069
Reaction score
5,679
Points
113
Gheez, Hilton gets a 15k fine on a roughing the passer penalty, that NEVER gets called on Ben? Minkah’s horse collar penalty generated a lesser fine $11+k.

I’m surprised they didn’t eject Bud since it looked like he dislocated a clavicle on his hit.


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
Clubs giveth and ol Godell loves to take 'em away.

yeah some of those fines are beyond ridiculous.
 
Ike Kelly said:
Gheez, Hilton gets a 15k fine on a roughing the passer penalty, that NEVER gets called on Ben? Minkah’s horse collar penalty generated a lesser fine $11+k.

I’m surprised they didn’t eject Bud since it looked like he dislocated a clavicle on his hit.

Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app
Click to expand...

It was a horse collar tackle. I said to myself 2 seconds after it happened, thats a flag and it won't shock me if there is a fine. With players getting hurt at an alarming rate, I believe the NFL is going to be extra harsh on foul penalties.

Ben doesn't get many roughing the passer calls. Speculation is he and Tomlin, who have had there share of fines are part of the reason as to why.
 
Coach said:
It was a horse collar tackle. I said to myself 2 seconds after it happened, thats a flag and it won't shock me if there is a fine. With players getting hurt at an alarming rate, I believe the NFL is going to be extra harsh on foul penalties.

Ben doesn't get many roughing the passer calls. Speculation is he and Tomlin, who have had there share of fines are part of the reason as to why.
Click to expand...

Alex I will take dumb *** sentences of the day for $1000 please.
 
Coach said:
It was a horse collar tackle. I said to myself 2 seconds after it happened, thats a flag and it won't shock me if there is a fine. With players getting hurt at an alarming rate, I believe the NFL is going to be extra harsh on foul penalties.

Ben doesn't get many roughing the passer calls. Speculation is he and Tomlin, who have had there share of fines are part of the reason as to why.
Click to expand...



Coach, part of the reason BEN ROETHLISBERGER doesn't get some of those calls is because his whole career he has used ESCAPEABILTY as a way of extending plays. The referees don't take that away from him.

AS for the blatant stuff, it has settled down and they do call more and more but in his earlier days including the VOTE against the "rog", they let everyone have open game on him to punish for that insane vote & Millagevillevill incident.




Salute the nation
 
Coach said:
It was a horse collar tackle. I said to myself 2 seconds after it happened, thats a flag and it won't shock me if there is a fine. With players getting hurt at an alarming rate, I believe the NFL is going to be extra harsh on foul penalties.

Ben doesn't get many roughing the passer calls. Speculation is he and Tomlin, who have had there share of fines are part of the reason as to why.
Click to expand...

Hilton’s penalty was a Roughing the Passer. Anyone who watched the game knew Minkah’s was a HC, plus it’s....in.....my......post. Why repeat it?

What speculation? Link please....or is it more diarrhea of the mouth?


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
slashsteel said:
Alex I will take dumb *** sentences of the day for $1000 please.
Click to expand...

Jeopardy%21_Season_19_Daily_Double_Logo.jpg
 
Ticky tacky in my opinion. I've stayed away because there have been some BLATANT calls MISSED by the officials against us but they OBVIOUSLY see everything we're doing on the field.

The NO CALL PI on Claypool yesterday almost got my neighbor's TV broke...:mad2:
 
You can chalk it up as random or realize the NFL has double standards against some people and a different set of rules for others.






Sent from my iPhone using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
You commenting on the fines, or the speculation on post #3. We are still waiting on the link.


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
Ike Kelly said:
You commenting on the fines, or the speculation on post #3. We are still waiting on the link.


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app
Click to expand...

Well this is false. You wrote " Gheez, Hilton gets a 15k fine on a roughing the passer penalty, that NEVER gets called on Ben " - Ike Taylor

Um, I have seen Ben get roughing the passer calls that were iffy.. You must NEVER watch those games.

It is my opinion the NFL doesn't call things evenly. If a defender's hand brushes over Tom Brady's hemet, it's likely to draw a flag. If Ben gets jacked up a second after the ball is throw, sometime there is no flag. You'd have to watch the games to understand this point.

 
Coach said:
It was a horse collar tackle. I said to myself 2 seconds after it happened, thats a flag and it won't shock me if there is a fine. With players getting hurt at an alarming rate, I believe the NFL is going to be extra harsh on foul penalties.
.
Click to expand...

If this was your post, it would have been perfect.

Ben got hit in the helmet and didn't draw a flag or a penalty, in that Denver game. I believe it was on their sack.
 
On the roughing the passer from Hilton. 1 and 2 steps before a QB hit is a flap of a hummingbird's wing. Real time, I thought for sure it was 1 step. On slow motion review it was 2 steps. Hilton is fast!

By rule, 2 steps is roughing after the ball is released, so I can't fault the penalty.

The fine would have to show me there was intent to hurt or injure the QB. I did not see that in the hit Hilton delivered. He pulled up and could have hit that QB a lot harder. I disagree strongly with assessing that play was fineable.
 
Coach said:
Well this is false. You wrote " Gheez, Hilton gets a 15k fine on a roughing the passer penalty, that NEVER gets called on Ben " - Ike Taylor

Um, I have seen Ben get roughing the passer calls that were iffy.. You must NEVER watch those games.

It is my opinion the NFL doesn't call things evenly. If a defender's hand brushes over Tom Brady's hemet, it's likely to draw a flag. If Ben gets jacked up a second after the ball is throw, sometime there is no flag. You'd have to watch the games to understand this point.

Click to expand...

For the love of God, get some reading comprehension lessons. The type of rough calls that get called against Pitt players (i.e. Hilton’s) rarely if ever gets called for Ben. The love tap by Hilton would never be called RTP against Ben.

If you had any higher understanding of English composition you would know my post is a statement by the writer. Unlike you, who posits “speculation” when you later state it’s your “opinion”. Those are two different word usage and exhibits one of two scenarios:

A. You got caught in stating a lie, or
B. You have a serious lack of reading comprehension.

I gave you the benefit of the doubt on the latter, since you are two ignorant to purposely concoct A.

Also, if I’m Ike Taylor, why are you even arguing with me? I know more about football than you would amass in three lifetimes.



Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
Yet the league did nothing to the three players first week that threw punches and hit an official plus ejected. Time for Rooney to stand up for his players.
 
black and gold apex said:
Yet the league did nothing to the three players first week that threw punches and hit an official plus ejected. Time for Rooney to stand up for his players.
Click to expand...


Rooney should be smart enough to know that the Steelers thanks to Tomlin and Ben ( Other like Brown and Bell don't help ) aren't going to get the calls as often. Even a bone head like Ike Kelly sees, it but arguing with the NFL and Roger isn't going to help.
 
On MNF, I saw Harbaugh aggressively yelling and making contact with an official. Where was the ejection?
 
Cope said:
On MNF, I saw Harbaugh aggressively yelling and making contact with an official. Where was the ejection?
Click to expand...
yep.

The sanctimonious coach was screaming and spittin on the nearest official when the Rats got that goofy penalty on offense.

Sent from my SM-N950W using Tapatalk
 
Coach said:
Rooney should be smart enough to know that the Steelers thanks to Tomlin and Ben ( Other like Brown and Bell don't help ) aren't going to get the calls as often. Even a bone head like Ike Kelly sees, it but arguing with the NFL and Roger isn't going to help.
Click to expand...

There you go again, implying Tomlin and Ben are the reason for non calls.

Please enlighten us Dumb *** as to why and how the Commish/league performs this statement. You won’t because you can’t and you can’t because there’s no proof to think so. I will say, there is preferential treatment for certain players. Brady, Rodgers, Brees and to an extent Rivers.


Sent from my iPad using Steeler Nation mobile app
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top